Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

1000FPS 4K Red Dragon

1000FPS 4K Red Dragon

  • Hell yes!

    Votes: 267 68.1%
  • No, high FPS is overrated

    Votes: 28 7.1%
  • No, too expensive

    Votes: 97 24.7%

  • Total voters
    392
Definitely. This would probably attract the carbon group, plus most rental houses/fx shops would add one. Be great to have it be anything from 1-1000. I'd be more the happy with 500fps. I even find 200 adequate for most situations but can always use more. It would have to be solid for a 24p cam though.
 
Competition is good, and RED likes to upset the apple cart of the market... which is good for users. I don't know if it makes sense to push a direct competitor for the Flex4K, (bandwidth management for 1000FPS RAW makes EVERYTHING really expensive, the 64GB cinemag cost more than my Epic M kit... at my last trip to Vision Research they mentioned that the bare sensor for the Flex4k is also more expensive than an Epic). Maybe something in between - 400-600fps.
 
Definitely. This would probably attract the carbon group, plus most rental houses/fx shops would add one. Be great to have it be anything from 1-1000. I'd be more the happy with 500fps. I even find 200 adequate for most situations but can always use more. It would have to be solid for a 24p cam though.

Yes, I agree. 500fps or "even" 300 would cover most of my needs.
/Andreas
 
I don't know why everyone keeps saying it will cover my needs at 500fps or less. We're not meeting your specific needs. If you build a high speed camera to compete it has to be close to or beat the specs of the competition, otherwise people will still buy/rent a Phantom... I agree that 500fps is fine for what I do, but why not push it further? Does 5k cover your needs, 6k, 4k? If RED just wanted to meet your needs we'd still have a 4K sensor.
 
To be clear, Jarred was very clear. This would be a whole new camera. Sensor, boards, the lot....
 
To be clear, Jarred was very clear. This would be a whole new camera. Sensor, boards, the lot....

Exactly. I don't think people read entire threads haha
 
To be clear, Jarred was very clear. This would be a whole new camera. Sensor, boards, the lot....

I got that... and maybe I should have elabarated. Dragon family chip? Basically Phantom stuff often sticks out when in Alexa Ads or shows and the really opertunity with a Epic HS camera is if the main and HS camweras match!

It is not that I wouldn't love a Dragon 'looking' HS camera that also does 1000fps+ BUT if what we end up with is something that looks like a Red FLex then I'd rather keep using VR products and buy a VIsta vision Dragon (for example)

Just trying to be realistic


M
 
I got that... and maybe I should have elabarated. Dragon family chip? Basically Phantom stuff often sticks out when in Alexa Ads or shows and the really opertunity with a Epic HS camera is if the main and HS camweras match!

Gotcha. I think it's a CMOS vs CCD thing in part but also something that people don't consider.

To my eye, contrast ratio's seem to behave differently at high speed, ie fractional differences are magnified at high speed.

Plus it's really hard to match lighting to regular speed stuff. Either by use of ND's or increasing intensity of light.
 
Plus it's really hard to match lighting to regular speed stuff.

100%.. I did a shoot the other day where I needed some 25fps material to match some 240fps material... We swaped my key light from a 800 HMI (joker) to a 9k HMI. I could see everyone thinking I had gone mad but actually we were bang on (when I drop from 5k ot 2k I also rate the camera much lower in EI terms)... so often I see people underestimating what they need and then compromising by: Bringing the lights in, underexposing and also changing the light shape (from soft to less soft to get more out of the lights)
 
If it is a Dragon Chip then I would be happy with 300fps 16:9 @ 5k (S35) .... I am asuming this would allow far faster 4k, 3k etc...

If we are talking about a completley other chip... iike the low latitude noisey VR chips then of course it should be 1000fps+

Did you have problems with the Flex4K? From what I saw working with the camera, noise was VERY low, I don't have a feel for latitude but I've seen references to anything from 10 to 13+ stops.
 
Sorry haven't shot on a flex 4k yet...

I have had noise challenges on the HD gold...

That said I am not knocking the phantom cameras. I love them and feel that there is no point offering similar.

I admire the way Red has stuck to its guns on Raw rather than copy the others with QT recording. In that spirit I want them always to offer something new and unique. They have a unique POV, and often I disagree, but they must stick to it. Other wise they become a copy company just competing on price. If they can bring something new to HS great but price is not enough for me. I felt that a camera that was HS and the A camera is unique!

Just my thoughts...

Regards

M
 
If they ever get the 4k flex bugs sorted it wouldn't be such a hassle on set, but the fact that all the apps for their models have consistently worked bad for years leaves little hope. If resolve 11 works, great, but at this point its been such a nightmare for me/others I talk to.

But if they ever get the prores working in the flex 4k it will solve many of the workflow problems... just have to settle for baked in footage though. But hey, at least the files will play and be there and work in any app! theres always that lol!

what scares me the most is when I hear about missing takes on the new flex 4k. Thats not a good thing to be hearing from a DP that just used one last week... when the week before you couldn't even make Seance function yourself in a relaxed class room environment, I imagine on set with it must be even crazier right now. Also helicopters blow them up fyi if you don't watch the power...

Highly unlikely that ProRes will ever be working in the Flex 4K, but ProRes does look like something that'll be coming to Seance in the future. The option is already sorta there, just not enabled. I've been pleased with the Seance updates and support so far. Great communication.

The .cine files from the Flex 4K are easily played back for quick reference with Quicktime7. The files are also easily managed in other applications.
 
How about v series like frame rates? ps maybe they could save on costs by not mandating a take needs to get off the ram on the mag in 10 seconds?
 
Sorry haven't shot on a flex 4k yet...

I have had noise challenges on the HD gold...

That said I am not knocking the phantom cameras. I love them and feel that there is no point offering similar.

I admire the way Red has stuck to its guns on Raw rather than copy the others with QT recording. In that spirit I want them always to offer something new and unique. They have a unique POV, and often I disagree, but they must stick to it. Other wise they become a copy company just competing on price. If they can bring something new to HS great but price is not enough for me. I felt that a camera that was HS and the A camera is unique!

Just my thoughts...

Regards

M

We've also got some of their HS cameras (Miros and a 1610) and those cameras all have noise issues when compared to cinema cameras. Since they're used for scientific work (which is really their intended market) it's something we live with in order to get the incredible frame rates... but knowing their output I actually didn't think anyone would use them for traditional media work. The Flex4K was something else entirely... it's definitely light hungry but the output was impressive. The biggest problem I had when researching the camera is that there's not a lot of information out there about it... not even a lot of video online (though that's improving), and some of the information is actually wrong (the spec's changed some between announcement and release). I ended up ordering it... and I think it was the right call... but it was a lot of $$$ and I ended up having to go to NJ to actually play with the camera to even get a feel for its capabilities. I still don't have any real test results for the camera (certainly not like the wealth of data on Epic, Arri, and other cinema cameras).
 
You're not gonna see V-series like frame rates from the Flex 4K. Most live action digital high speed photography is between 500-1,500fps any way. The Flex 4K is more geared towards being a cine camera with high-speed capabilities, not replacing the Flex or V-series cameras. Look at the sensitivity between the Flex and it's 4K counterpart ... then tell me which one you'd prefer for a table top job. They all have their respective place, though.


How about v series like frame rates? ps maybe they could save on costs by not mandating a take needs to get off the ram on the mag in 10 seconds?
 
Highly unlikely that ProRes will ever be working in the Flex 4K, but ProRes does look like something that'll be coming to Seance in the future. The option is already sorta there, just not enabled. I've been pleased with the Seance updates and support so far. Great communication.

The .cine files from the Flex 4K are easily played back for quick reference with Quicktime7. The files are also easily managed in other applications.

I agree that I doubt we'll see prores out of the camera directly... but it's easy to export cine files to ProRes from the VR app. The folks at Adobe seem to be hinting that they'll also be supported natively by CC in the near future.
 
Hi Jarred,

Let's just say this just arrived in my studio and I am about to buy a Phantom. I need 800/1000 FPS in 2k + . No need for more. Thank you RED for listening.


[url=https://www.flickr.com/photos/90607088@N06/13859664273/]
Sans titre par frederic.ca, sur Flickr[/URL]
 
You're not gonna see V-series like frame rates from the Flex 4K. Most live action digital high speed photography is between 500-1,500fps any way. The Flex 4K is more geared towards being a cine camera with high-speed capabilities, not replacing the Flex or V-series cameras. Look at the sensitivity between the Flex and it's 4K counterpart ... then tell me which one you'd prefer for a table top job. They all have their respective place, though.

You can get into the 10kfps area with the flex4k... But because of the sensor design, specifying narrower frames doesn't scale frame rate (has to do with how it reads out)... So a 256 x 256 window will read at the same rate as a 2048 x 256. No 100kfps rates for the flex4k.
 
Back
Top