Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

1000FPS 4K Red Dragon

1000FPS 4K Red Dragon

  • Hell yes!

    Votes: 267 68.1%
  • No, high FPS is overrated

    Votes: 28 7.1%
  • No, too expensive

    Votes: 97 24.7%

  • Total voters
    392
Leave the 1000-2000 fps stuff to Vision Research and Weisscam since this is indeed a specialty thing. But 500-750 fps would be great as an add on either in burst mode or not.

heh heh..... specialty or not, I have a special place in my heart for the high speed stuff.

Before RED, I met with a bunch of machine vision manufactures with my buddy Nick and we had a pretty grand ( and completely unrealistic ) idea of building a high speed camera that could shoot both 24fps as well as high speed for cinema. For some reason Vision Research ( which back then was making industrial cameras ) had faith in us and let us muck around with their stuff and tweak things just enough for us to get in way over our heads. I am pretty sure they thought we were nuts.

I can't believe this website is still up.... I don't think it has been touched for more than a decade. Pretty dopey stuff but remembering back then it was sure alot of fun.

http://purposelabs.com/
 
This would be a great feature. If it offers 500fps then people are gonna want 1000fps so I think that is where to aim. 2000fps is defo in specialist territory.

A buffer system like the phantom is the way to go.

Potential problems I see are... on dragon 4k has a field of view considerably smaller than s35, compression at these rates introduces iq issues not evident at lower fps, black shading already takes too long (on MX, not sure if we are at acceptable times on dragon yet), and this is an issue because on high speed shoots it is normal in my experience to test different fps before settling on the desired spreed.

edit Jarred posted while I was writing, still think >1000fps is pushing it...possible with a new cam tho....
 
Well the phantom 4k was already om my shoppimg list for some day,
if red could pull this together asap at a reasonable price I am all in
this would place red again ahead of competition and put them back to the excitement where it all started,
think you really have to do this Jarred
guess you well sell many more then monochromes
 
nope.. Would need a new sensor and new boards.. i.e a whole different camera.
So you're saying there is no way to do a hardware upgrade to the current MX/Dragon Epics to make this happen? Not necessarily full high speed but limiting it to 9-18 second windows to shoot in?
 
Actually, thinking about this in relation to the 4K broadcst module....

Combine High-speed with dragons equipped with the new module and you have a pretty kick ass sports eco-system. The only downside being in this scenario the sensor real estate is possibly a bit big at 4k...

Gonna need some new big ass broadcast zooms!
 
I voted yes albeit I couldn't afford it at the moment.
I would love to rent it and if funding wouldn't be a problem I would go RED instead of VR. Just make sure to use the same module sets so for power etc it can remain the same.
 
Higher frame rate shooting at high 4K+ is one of RED's big selling points, so my vote definitely goes for pushing this further. Can't see us really needing more than say 250fps though, anything higher and we'd hire a specialist camera. We've used the FS700 on a few projects recently and the 240 fps mode is really nice.
 
nope.. Would need a new sensor and new boards.. i.e a whole different camera.

Is it possible it could have the same look?

If not I would say don't do 1000fps but concentrate on a smaller upgrade to frame rate and keep a matching camera set.

I have a small studio with some bigger 1000hz lamps (like the new k5600 9k) and have done a fair bit of HS. 1000fps stuff that matches the look feel of other material shot at 24/25 always seems to wrong foot people from a lighting POV.

I would be happy to buy a HS dragon that matches but if it does not then happy to keep hireling in phantoms...

Ps I wish this poll did not mention price... There is too much spec not defined to pin a price up.
 
nope.. Would need a new sensor and new boards.. i.e a whole different camera.

Just for the curious non-tech guys of us: in what way does the sensor need to be different?
Is it some kind of refresh rate or is it something else entirely like light sensitivity or all of it?
 
Leave the 1000-2000 fps stuff to Vision Research and Weisscam since this is indeed a specialty thing.

As is the monochrome :) (a speciality thing)

RED has already been pondering about this even before this thread (and the many others like it). As Jim quite often said: it all depends on price and units sold.
I'm sure they could build it if they wanted to. They only didn't want to focus on that kind of camera as Jim stated before.

But now since dragon is completely done, maybe they have some air to breathe and spend more time thinking about the 645, 617 and other speciality kind of cameras.

Of course it would be safer to find enough people to commit to a 5k@1000fps RED camera at a certain price point and then start developing it. Kinda like a kickstarter campaign.
By now I'm pretty sure that RED could estimate somewhat more safely, how difficult and maybe even how expensive an approach like that would be for them.

Tom Lowe would be one of the first to jump in on a 5K 1000fps RED camera. ;)
 
Its more then just Vision Research price point. The reality is they really provide worse support then Red, its a battle dealing with them. Everything is buggy, from the actual non third party stuff, to the third party stuff (by third party I mean the one person coding in the world for this camera, besides resolve 11 which I am praying will be stable). I just got 4k Flex trained and our encodes stuttered, Seance would crash all the time. Its kind of a bag of hurt over there to be honest. People like to talk about Red delays but Vision Research will take a long time to fill all the 4k Flex backorders... I like the Alexa rip off of an interface, once prores is enabled that will be pretty sweet too, so its not all bad folks, but I just wanted to point out that they do have lots of issues over there, not just with price but with logistics like any relatively smaller camera company. I been trying for weeks to get them to upgrade my ram in my Miro, and the tech says its possible but no one seems to get back to me with a quote. At this point I am quite literally begging them to take my money. But the reality is the 4k flex backorder is the priority and thats probably why I am getting no where fast.. I am going to continue trying to pay them regardless though lol... will bug them next week when I have down time


The 4k Flex class at Abel NYC ended up shooting some low res 10,000fps shots on the 4k flex, but Seance kept crashing with it, a match took 78 minutes to playback and I got a cine file to prove it. Jamie, the instructor was joking with us about how we were taking a high speed high res camera and shooting so low res with it, but its an important feature. I think being able to dial in not just preset pixel counts, but custom ones for niche stuff is awesome though, so if Red would be willing to look into a high speed camera I think as much as everyone wants high res, at least please allow a way for low res but faster fps, because in some shoots that is just as important. I mean even a miro at low res can do a 100,000fps, and I know most people don't see a use in it, but man some pyrotechnics or guns or just basically watch "the slowmo guys" or "skateology" on youtube, that is the kind of stuff that really stokes me out to see, and sometimes high res isn't the priority is all, but the aesthetic of the slower images.

Also I know a lot of people are actually a bit bummed that the 4k flex cannot go as fast as the 2k flex. The menu is much better though, and the mags don't get loose and unmount mistakenly, there are a lot of improvements so I don't want to come off too negative, but my point is there is definitely interest in higher speeds. Some people in the class had recently bought a 2k flex over the 4k simply for the speed.

So I just wanted to lay it all our there, its more then just high speed, its the red ecosystem that is already substantially more stable that attracts me to a Red high speed product. People try to knock reds, go do a phantom job and get back to me about stability. I think a module would be a cool possibility but the technology/engineering for that may not be possible. Maybe if it had ram in the external recorder, but the refresh rates on the sensor is not designed for the massive change. Also not sure if cmos/non global shutter would be the best combos for this, adapting our current cameras whether hardware/firmware just simply isn't an option is my guess.

But whatever man, if you build a new model consider me the first one financing it. I wanna be at ground zero on that sign up sheet!
 
Last edited:
4k or 5k:

500fps x 10seconds = 5000frames
5000 frames played back at 24fps = 208 seconds =3,5minute playback .... well, at least you fill up red-mags quickly ;)

we could do well with this:
240fps x 7 seconds = 1680frames
1680 frames played back at 24fps = 70 seconds

if you want more then twixtor is there.

This is of course guesswork thinking within the box, the geniuses always seem to ignore that box. What do I know :)
 
Twixtor is why people shoot high speed to begin with though, it can't work in so many applications, you have to have it framed just right, certain subjects don't work, no straight lines behind subject...its just too much of a creative killer, too many rules to make it even function in most instances without some problems. I think being able to dial in a range of settings is key, whether we are talking resolution, frame rates, etc. Longer takes can be possible, but probably need to be shot at lower resolution... and no matter what they set as the max resolution buffer, some people will always want a longer shot, which is where tweaking down from 5k or 4k suddenly starts to matter. if 3k gets you a long enough roll, I am sure most people will be happier, better then missing some head or tail on a shot. So regardless of the maximum specs on fps or resolution, malleability is key for real world shooting
 
Last edited:
I'd really appreciate and use a burst mode implemented in actual cameras. If you're going to produce another camera, I'd much prefer if you were going smaller (good DR and redcode in a lighter body that can shoot 1h+ with 1 Redvolt)
 
Back
Top