Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

Weapon worth it? Poll time

Weapon worth it? Poll time

  • Upgrading to 8K Vista

    Votes: 29 10.3%
  • Upgrading to 6K Weapon

    Votes: 14 5.0%
  • Neutral

    Votes: 57 20.2%
  • Disappointed

    Votes: 182 64.5%

  • Total voters
    282
Well a lot of the weapon features & pricing on this round seem to me to be more for the A list crowd and rental houses, rather then the smaller owner/operator/renters. Also owner/operator/renters way outnumber the ASC type crowd on reduser, so i'd expect some problems with the pole here. I do think RED had to focus on the ASC and Network crowd for features for weapon, otherwise long term it would not have been good for RED and reduser.

I kindly disagree. Hollywood and TV-Shows with budget are mostly shot on Arri unless the smaller form factor of the Epic excels in a 3D-rig. The ASC crowd shoots Arri and with the new Arri Mini even more Arri. Arnold & Richter has it's home-market back.

The high-end stills market, hybrid projects, genres like fashion are a realm where the new 8k FF sensor Red camera will find it's new friends. Hollywood is shooting S-35mm or 65mm. For both Arri has a good answer. Skulls, nerdy names, military style, saw blades and metal spiders don't help selling a camera system to the academy members., perhaps to there pierced staff. At some point the naughty boy has to become grown up. Carrying a camera with a skull on it and written weapon in fat letters on its side may cause some embarrassment, depending what kin of job you do.

I recently interviewed a nobel price winner in chemistry. Showing up with such a childish device at such a job is not a particular good idea. It will only bring up questions that don't help the job. I'm not going to imagine an interview with an Auschwitz survivor. Dragon on the other hand makes people smile.

Personally I think that not everything regarding the third generation of Red cameras is well thought out.



Hans
 
All you guys complaining about the Upgrade price need to really consider NOBODY in the industry does this. We are LUCKY that RED even has this option. If you don't want to upgrade you can sell your camera and buy the weapon, it will probably be more cost effective but then you will be WITHOUT a camera until all the other orders are filled. The point is if you actually make real money with your camera then the Upgrade makes sense so you can keep your camera working. And lets face it WE ALL WANT VISTA VISTA weather we can afford it or not. RED just BLEW camera world up with a FULL FRAME 8K sensor in a carbon body! Nobody even comes close, so once again RED is setting the stage for the future because eventually most pro cameras will go FULL FRAME.
 
All you guys complaining about the Upgrade price need to really consider NOBODY in the industry does this. We are LUCKY that RED even has this option. If you don't want to upgrade you can sell your camera and buy the weapon, it will probably be more cost effective but then you will be WITHOUT a camera until all the other orders are filled. The point is if you actually make real money with your camera then the Upgrade makes sense so you can keep your camera working. And lets face it WE ALL WANT VISTA VISTA weather we can afford it or not. RED just BLEW camera world up with a FULL FRAME 8K sensor in a carbon body! Nobody even comes close, so once again RED is setting the stage for the future because eventually most pro cameras will go FULL FRAME.

Photographers are only ones that want that vista vision stuff. Id like to use the great lenses that lens makers have spent decades perfecting for my cinema use. Vista vision is gonna be a nightmare for post.
 
Personally I think that not everything regarding the third generation of Red cameras is well thought out. Hans

I don't agree; If anything, VVeapon is super thought out.
And I suspect we still don't even know the half of it.

I think the disappoint lays with the growning-pains costs. (more then many thought, myself included);
there isn't an outright problem with the camera itself. (frankly, I think it was smart to limit ProRes to 2K)

Nothing else does what weapon CF 8K will do at ANY cost:
FF, 8K, RAW + ProRes, truly amazing tech in a smart meticulously thought out design that functions as a platform.

Think 16 times the image size of 2K w/ a massive FOV, giving us super-sampled retina-like 4K.

Sure its expensive, more then I like, but it makes sense.


If you don't have to be the first kid on the block to do FF 8K, wait a couple years.
(you'll probably want to wait on new Intel chips/TB3/etc anyways)


Epic Dragon is still awesome, and the promised features are still tricking in
(check the latest beta firmwares).
 
Photographers are only ones that want that vista vision stuff. Id like to use the great lenses that lens makers have spent decades perfecting for my cinema use. Vista vision is gonna be a nightmare for post.

I tend to disagree... not only are cameras advancing at an incredible rate, but so are computers and NLEs.
 
And lets face it WE ALL WANT VISTA VISTA weather we can afford it or not. RED just BLEW camera world up with a FULL FRAME 8K sensor in a carbon body!

Before the 8k weapon announcement I even didn't know that there has been a format called Vista Vision. I never touched a Vista camera, never sah a picture of one I'm now 48, quite time in the industry and teach every here and then filmmaking at university. Vista was never ever in my life a subject. Now Vista is on everyone's lips - in capital letters. Marketing.

Hans
 
I have spent way more money, and now i just can't keep doing this its way too much. The price needs to go way down, very disappointing in the pricing.
 
Don't know why I am bothering to reply...but here goes nothing.

To me the Weapon 'upgrade' is nothing more than a bug-fix release. All the improvements are basic features that should have been in the Dragon in the first place! The fact that Red can charge more money for a bug-fix -and some consumers are even happy to buy it- shows just how far ahead of the competition they truly are. Now it is upto the likes of Sony, Panasonic, Blackmagic et al to step up and give us consumers some choice. (I won't include Canon in that list, joke of a company that has only survived past few years because of its established lens system.)
 
After a long love relationship ( serial #211 ---first of six cams ) I smell divorce papers on the air.

Sad

G
 
I guess you guys haven't really thought what it means that RED has gone from a "sole distributor" model into a "normal distribution" model.

That is a good thing at this stage.
But also in all practical terms means a price-hike for endusers.
 
To me the Weapon 'upgrade' is nothing more than a bug-fix release. All the improvements are basic features that should have been in the Dragon in the first place! The fact that Red can charge more money for a bug-fix -and some consumers are even happy to buy it- shows just how far ahead of the competition they truly are.

Some consumers may be happy to buy it, no doubt. I think that RED should consider the Weapon camera rollout a HIT only if a LOT of consumers are happy to buy it. Since we don't know the order numbers, we don't know -- but if the orders are rolling it at RED, then, they are good to go. If they are not, hopefully, they'll reconsider some of the elements of this rollout and pivot.

My personal take remains that they should have made the EPIC DRAGON -> WEAPON DRAGON a no-brainer update. It'd have helped RED sell more of the new accessories and move its user base into the future if most of them had taken on this upgrade asap. Maybe they still will - I don't know the full story. Let's see what comes to pass. But I know I will pass on this upgrade at this pricing level.
 
I guess you guys haven't really thought what it means that RED has gone from a "sole distributor" model into a "normal distribution" model.

That is a good thing at this stage.
But also in all practical terms means a price-hike for endusers.

If this is true, then the abelcine news was TERRIBLE news! ;)
 
My 2 cents (which I should keep to go to Weapon)

After the initial shock and doing the math, I have to admit its not a bad deal. If we look at each individual component in the upgrade "path", it would mean that we were paying 9900 for the brain upgrade (for non M or CF Dragons), which is basically what we expected since the beginning. What Red did was basically a "Stage 3" (for those that remember the stages situation in the red one to Epic upgrade times).

For me, excluding the top handle, every single item of the bundle (I am a primary red volt shooter) is essential. I would much prefer a side handle kind of control then the new redmote - side control hybrid, but that's probably how things are thought out for the future. Add the 5000 USD store credit and one can have 3x 240gb cards plus reader- a ready to shoot package for 16000 USD. Which is kind of reasonable.

The main problem I have, and that on a personal level, is the following:


My Dragon upgrade notice came last year about May or June, if I'm not mistaken. I could only get the funds by September, which means I only got to use my Dragon for less than a year. I still haven't recovered my investment. I can't get 5000 USD for the deposit in 5 days to warrant the 5000 store credit. I was hoping and thinking this was part of the "pre NAB vote of confidence" reward gave us for going Dragon. I got an email saying I need to put 5000 USD or I lose the accessories credit. This puts the Weapon upgrade from 16 000 to 21 000 realistic working unit. This is too much for a struggling, somehow recognised for its work but yet poorly paid filmmaker/content creator like me.

The second aspect which I can't believe is that most of us independents that can't afford Carbon Fibre Weapon seem to be out of Red's love for future upgrades. It feels like RED is aiming at Peter Jackson, Universal, Roger Deakins, all these who work on million dollar projects. The stablished ones. I am part probably of a big majority of lesser known hopefuls or content creators, who while not at the scope of the established ones, create memorable, groundbreaking or important work for our respective markets/locations. The Sundances, the Independent Festivals, the Music Videos, Web Videos, Regional Movies are made from content made from the Non Carbon Fibre, non M users. It feels like we have just been labeled "lower class" by RED, and cannot benefit from their future technology. I feel a bit like a bastard son.

So I stand here in hope of 2 things: Red, Jarred, please maintain the 5000 USD Credit for us Red Dragon upgraders prior NAB until the end of the Year. We need to get financing ready, its just too soon to go 5000 USD in 5 days.

Jarred and RED Team, please reassure us Magnesium only capable that we are still in the upgrade path by going Magnesium. We (I speak obviously on a personal level) can wait longer, but would really love to keep growing with you and your advancements!
 
Some consumers may be happy to buy it, no doubt. I think that RED should consider the Weapon camera rollout a HIT only if a LOT of consumers are happy to buy it. Since we don't know the order numbers, we don't know -- but if the orders are rolling it at RED, then, they are good to go. If they are not, hopefully, they'll reconsider some of the elements of this rollout and pivot.

My personal take remains that they should have made the EPIC DRAGON -> WEAPON DRAGON a no-brainer update. It'd have helped RED sell more of the new accessories and move its user base into the future if most of them had taken on this upgrade asap. Maybe they still will - I don't know the full story. Let's see what comes to pass. But I know I will pass on this upgrade at this pricing level.

Yes, the pricing is the real disappointment for most of us. At the same time, no one else is offering the capability of Red's Weapon at any price point, so how much can we complain. I guess we have all become somewhat spoilt by the big leaps in past and Red have reached the point of diminishing returns as far as DSMC technology is concerned. Let us get used to these kind of 'upgrades'.

What bothers me is this huge gap between the consumer grade Panasonic GH4 and Red Weapon, with nothing truly ground breaking in-between. There is nothing very attractive between $2000 and $60,000 if you like shooting 12bit (or more) RAW. Ursa Mini 4.6K is most interesting of the lot, but it looks like BMD need another twelve months of R&D before they hit the nail on its head.
 
It's definitely worth it if you're a filmmaker that needs to shoot the next epic film. But for me, a small business owner, who does online ads it's not worth it. But I totally believe the Epic/Scarlet Dragon is definitely worth it.

I imagine it's insanely tough for Red to be the market leader in this category, while continually offering products for the base/original customers. Perhaps that is why they stretched their offerings to meet the needs of everything between prosumers to world-class. Very tough indeed.

I do think their approach to modularity is a very hopeful sign to come—I don't know of any other camera company that comes close. Hopefully they can extend that to electronics and sensors? :)
 
Disappointed in price and plan vs features / Roi. Love the camera though.
 
Panasonic is finally doing some interesting things again...


Yes, the pricing is the real disappointment for most of us. At the same time, no one else is offering the capability of Red's Weapon at any price point, so how much can we complain. I guess we have all become somewhat spoilt by the big leaps in past and Red have reached the point of diminishing returns as far as DSMC technology is concerned. Let us get used to these kind of 'upgrades'.

What bothers me is this huge gap between the consumer grade Panasonic GH4 and Red Weapon, with nothing truly ground breaking in-between. There is nothing very attractive between $2000 and $60,000 if you like shooting 12bit (or more) RAW. Ursa Mini 4.6K is most interesting of the lot, but it looks like BMD need another twelve months of R&D before they hit the nail on its head.
 
Yes, the pricing is the real disappointment for most of us. At the same time, no one else is offering the capability of Red's Weapon at any price point, so how much can we complain. I guess we have all become somewhat spoilt by the big leaps in past and Red have reached the point of diminishing returns as far as DSMC technology is concerned. Let us get used to these kind of 'upgrades'.

What bothers me is this huge gap between the consumer grade Panasonic GH4 and Red Weapon, with nothing truly ground breaking in-between. There is nothing very attractive between $2000 and $60,000 if you like shooting 12bit (or more) RAW. Ursa Mini 4.6K is most interesting of the lot, but it looks like BMD need another twelve months of R&D before they hit the nail on its head.

You haven't seen or tried the Ursamini, I'm not sure what R&D BM has to do. The specs are through the roof. You can create a specs comparison chart in Excel, you will see that specs wise the UrsaMini is up there with the best. We have all seen and used footage from the BMcc 2.5k, it is very good. The 4k not so much. I wouldn't discount them. Their limitations are the same as most other cameras out there lowlight ISO, CMOS skew and image dots. From the footage we have seen its very organic, much like the Ikonoshop D16. The Ursa is no Weapon or Dragon, but along with the Canon its the newest horse in the race.
 
Back
Top