Rudi Herbert
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jun 1, 2007
- Messages
- 1,433
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
Jim,
As far as I know, Piranha 3D did not shoot native 3D underwater, but resorted to converting all uw footage in post. I was consulted very early on in the project, but they were set on using beam splitter rigs which, after some testing, were determined unsuitable due to unbalanced light transmission and mirror reflections between the cameras, so they decided to bypass the side-by-side option altogether and deemed underwater 3d an "impossibility", so they shot 2D and converted in post.
The EX1 with Fathom super wide is by far my favorite underwater set up, including RED, for its outstanding quality and portability, that is compared to the bulk of either RED or Aquavision underwater. Shooting to the Nano Flash will increase quality considerably but what will be even better is shooting to the Cinedeck, which records to 10 bit Cineform instead of 8 bit MPEG 2. The Cinedeck does not fit inside the Gates housing as does the Nano, but it would be very easy to build a custom housing for it, since it is basically a box, and run a SDI cable from the Gates housing to the Cinedeck housing, which would be mounted on top of the Gates. This is the set up I'm contemplating for a project later in the year. Mike should be able to build a housing for the Cinedeck easily and you would have a much more robust format than the Nano Flash. Lastly, I've developed a few Picture Profiles for the EX-1 for different kinds of water conditions, blue, green, clear, murky, deep, shallow, etc, etc and I'll be happy to share them with you.
As far as I know, Piranha 3D did not shoot native 3D underwater, but resorted to converting all uw footage in post. I was consulted very early on in the project, but they were set on using beam splitter rigs which, after some testing, were determined unsuitable due to unbalanced light transmission and mirror reflections between the cameras, so they decided to bypass the side-by-side option altogether and deemed underwater 3d an "impossibility", so they shot 2D and converted in post.
The EX1 with Fathom super wide is by far my favorite underwater set up, including RED, for its outstanding quality and portability, that is compared to the bulk of either RED or Aquavision underwater. Shooting to the Nano Flash will increase quality considerably but what will be even better is shooting to the Cinedeck, which records to 10 bit Cineform instead of 8 bit MPEG 2. The Cinedeck does not fit inside the Gates housing as does the Nano, but it would be very easy to build a custom housing for it, since it is basically a box, and run a SDI cable from the Gates housing to the Cinedeck housing, which would be mounted on top of the Gates. This is the set up I'm contemplating for a project later in the year. Mike should be able to build a housing for the Cinedeck easily and you would have a much more robust format than the Nano Flash. Lastly, I've developed a few Picture Profiles for the EX-1 for different kinds of water conditions, blue, green, clear, murky, deep, shallow, etc, etc and I'll be happy to share them with you.