Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

steps to avoid Noise and Softness

Les C.

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 24, 2009
Messages
813
Reaction score
0
Points
0
There are many users new to the RED cameras who have concerns about noise and softness that are solvable by implementing a good workflow.

This will hopefully end up being a comprehensive list that I (or someone with more skills in this area like Graeme Nattress?) can edit with additional suggestions and flesh out.

My initial suggestions are meant as a starting point for users new to the RED workflow, which involves preparation before shooting as well as post production.

I'd love it if someone at RED wanted to take this over and make it a sticky. A sticky on Black Shading would also be very useful.

Potential RED users visit these forums - and they see all these threads about noise and softness and other issues that are really caused by poor workflow.

If there were 'official' sticky threads on the 'correct' workflows from RED, these potential purchasers wouldn't see these threads from people confused about the basics of using RED cameras - they would see more threads about refining successful techniques and getting great images. Everybody wins.


----- Before Shooting ------

1. Black shade at the shutter speed and temperature you will shoot. ISO, format and frames per second do not affect the black shade process. Proper Black Shading will minimize noise.

Be sure to warm the sensor up to operating temperature before Black Shading.

The first temperature readout in the bottom status bar is the sensor temperature.

A good tip for checking whether or not to run black shading is this:

a. Let the camera come up to temperature
b. Put a lens cap on the camera for a nice flat black field
c. Crank the ISO to 12800

If you observe a nice flat field image, your calibration is good and you don't need to black shade.

A deviation of only 5 to 10 degrees in sensor may affect your noise levels.

Fan speed will affect sensor temperature.

2. purchase high quality glass and filters. A soft lens will result in soft images - and every additional filter affects the image to some degree. A lens is sharpest 3 stops above wide open.

3. Possibly set Back Focus for your lens? (actually, only a professional should do this. The basic steps are outlined here for RED's earlier camera: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jW9e2H_-Bk ) This will affect whether focus at infinity is valid and whether the distance markings on the lens are valid but will not affect your ability to focus.



----- During Shooting ------

1. verify that camera temperature is close to temperature of last black shade. A 5 or 10 degree difference will affect noise levels to some degree.

2. verify focus. The infinity mark may not actually be focused at infinity. See Back Focus above.

3. verify enough Light. Under-exposed scenes = more noise. Even the blacks need light to avoid noise. You can crush them later in post. The author of the following post has several other interesting posts in this thread on noise levels http://www.reduser.net/forum/showth...e-and-Softness&p=990426&viewfull=1#post990426

4. Expose to the right. http://www.luminous-landscape.com/tutorials/optimizing_exposure.shtml

5. Use the exposure tools in the RED camera
http://www.red.com/learn/red-101/exposure-with-red-cameras
http://www.reduser.net/forum/showth...Share-your-methods-please&highlight=practices

6. Be aware of the type of lighting. Tungsten lighting is noisy as it has very little blue as the blue and red channels only have 1/2 as many pixels as the green channel. This can result in clipping in the red channel. A CTB gel converts tungsten light of 3200K to 'daylight' color.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_correction

7. White Balance (easiest do do while shooting. Graeme prefers to white balance off a neutral gray card to not pick up reflected light)

Note: there's an advanced menu to calculate white balance, and several ways to get to it:

Touch and hold the Kelvin menu with the touch screen or scroll to the Kelvin window with the Side Handle and press the 'up' key.

In this menu, you can set Kelvin and Tint manually and "Calc White Balance".

8. Stabilize the camera from vibration.

9. Shoot 800 to preserve highlights. If you regularly use a light meter on all the areas of the shot, shoot 320

10. Higher compression can make your video seem less noisy as noise gets compressed away, but it will also have less detail. A very 'busy' scene will need lower compression to preserve detail.

11. The native color temperature of the Mysterium X sensor is 5000 Kelvin. Try to shoot between 5000-5600K by using filtration on the camera or on the light source, especially when shooting tungsten. Shooting outside of this range could result in more noise.

http://www.reduser.net/forum/showth...e-and-Softness&p=985127&viewfull=1#post985127

http://www.reduser.net/forum/showth...e-and-Softness&p=985146&viewfull=1#post985146

12. To avoid fan noise, try 35% manual for recording as a starting point (depending on ambient temperature). Standby speed will be higher, but ... it's unclear if a very high standby fan will reduce the temperature so much that your shooting temperature will differ from the black shade temperature and thus introduce noise. So, having a standby less than 100% might be advisable. The goal should be a stable temperature where the fan doesn't kick on 100% during recording (as it will if it reaches a certain internal temperature).


----- Post Production -----

1. R3D files have no sharpening applied. They will look 'soft' without sharpening.

2. R3D files have not been de-noised. NeatVideo.com is perfect for this - which can also sharpen.

3. The result may an image that looks very different from when the same lens is used on your DSLR. This is normal. Those DSLR images have been sharpened and de-noised to some degree. With R3D files, all the magic happens in post.

4. Be sure to view the image at (1:1) 100% to judge. Also be aware of your de-bayer settings.
http://www.reduser.net/forum/showth...e-and-Softness&p=986625&viewfull=1#post986625

5. Set White Balance BEFORE converting to RGB space for grading
http://www.reduser.net/forum/showthread.php?40067-Thoughts-and-Tips&p=539836&viewfull=1#post539836

6. The bayer pattern sensor used in RED cameras means that if you shoot at 4K, you get 4K * 80% = 3.2K of actual resolution. If you look at 4K blown up at 100% and are unhappy, try looking at it at 80%.

Check these two links to understand Bayer patterns:

http://www.reduser.net/forum/showthread.php?40067-Thoughts-and-Tips&p=539848&viewfull=1#post539848
http://magazine.creativecow.net/article/the-truth-about-2k-4k-the-future-of-pixels

Remember that even though 4K yields 3.2K of actual resolution, 'The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo' was shot in both 4K and 5K on the RED. 4K after processing will still be good enough for a movie projected at 4K, as was the Dragon Tattoo - and will be superb when down-rezzed to 1080p, which is the reality for those of us not making a feature movie.
 
Last edited:
Sorry to say but IMHO, this list sort of goes all over the place - including some questionable places (back focus being one, and you shouldn't have to "de-noise" well exposed footage)- and ends up not being all that helpful or (pun intended) "focused." Sorry - just my take.
 
I don't understand how people are getting all this noise. I shot an entire feature in 2009 on a Red One (M not MX), with only a small Tungsten lighting package, and there wasn't a spec of noise in a single shot.
 
I don't understand how people are getting all this noise. I shot an entire feature in 2009 on a Red One (M not MX), with only a small Tungsten lighting package, and there wasn't a spec of noise in a single shot.

It's easy: shoot with whatever lighting was there when you arrived on location, with no attempt to bring the dynamic range in front of the camera within the camera's sweet spot (~12 stops) and no attempt to maintain consistent color balance throughout the scene.

Is it really shocking that people who can barely afford a Scarlet also can't afford to properly control the lighting in a scene?
 
Thank you for the time and effort, Les!

This is an excellent resource for those individuals new to the Red workflow, and I think that Red should really take this and run with it, so to speak. This kind of information needs to be in the manual so that people are properly informed. While most of us understand the Red workflow, it is very easy to see why people get frustrated at their new '4k' camera resolving something closer to 3.2k.

Thank you once again for being so helpful, as I now have a place to send people who ask me: "Why is the footage out of focus?"
 
Les, you've basically covered all ground there....nice work. Not sure what BRANDON is laughing about either.....it's an excellent post for people to run through the list and check things off if they aren't getting the results they'd hoped for.
 
OK - let's start with Back Focus; I am happy to have someone correct me if I am wrong here but unless you are using the distance marks on your lens to determine your focus, back focus very likely has little or nothing to do with whether your image is in focus (unless it is WAAAAAAY off). Given there is no really good way to dial in perfect back focus (at least with your Canon mount) and the likelihood of your back focus being way off as it comes from RED is very low), 99% of people probably SHOULDN'T mess with the back focus adjustment.

If you are using all the other tools on your Scarlet to determine focus, this is most likely a total non-issue.
 
"While balance" - I assume this is a typo and means "white balance" -

WB in RAW is metadata; can be changed any time in post. Someone will have to explain to me why this effects focus or noise in a well exposed image. :huh:
 
White Balance will never effect your focus. However it could effect your noise as the native color temperature of the Mysterium X is 5000 Kelvin. I do my best to shoot at 5000-5600k and use filtration when shooting tungsten to bring the color temperature up most of the time. You dont have to mind you, as you can correct this later and still get great results.
 
The feature I shot in '09 was the first time I ever touched a Red camera, and it came out perfect. In other words, there's nothing 'Red specific' that should cause your shots to be soft or noisy. I just translated everything I've ever learned from other cameras to the Red and that was it. If you know how to shoot, you'll have no trouble getting a perfect image on a Red, or any other professional camera... If you're still learning how to shoot, this list should be helpful.
 
White Balance will never effect your focus. However it could effect your noise as the native color temperature of the Mysterium X is 5000 Kelvin. I do my best to shoot at 5000-5600k and use filtration when shooting tungsten to bring the color temperature up most of the time. You dont have to mind you, as you can correct this later and still get great results.

I'm going to ask a total novice question here, but when you say you "use filtration when shooting tungsten", you mean you are gelling the lights bluer, or you are adding blue filtration infront of the lens....ie in your matte box? I ask because I remember reading that on Dragon Tattoo they would add a filter infront of the camera to compensate for the REDs native color temperature...So wonder if you are doing something similar...

thx...

and again...sorry for sounding so junior...!
 
Totally depends on what I'm doing, but for VFX work I use glass filters in front of the camera. If its just a light source I'll sometimes gel them instead or use a diachroic filter on it. Several ways to tackle this depending on your shooting situation.
 
OK - let's start with Back Focus; I am happy to have someone correct me if I am wrong here but unless you are using the distance marks on your lens to determine your focus, back focus very likely has little or nothing to do with whether your image is in focus (unless it is WAAAAAAY off). Given there is no really good way to dial in perfect back focus (at least with your Canon mount) and the likelihood of your back focus being way off as it comes from RED is very low), 99% of people probably SHOULDN'T mess with the back focus adjustment.

If you are using all the other tools on your Scarlet to determine focus, this is most likely a total non-issue.

I mentioned that as someone had 'focused' by moving their lens to infinity, and they were having some issues with softness. I've seen a few threads where the back focus was off, but ... agreed, no one should try to adjust back focus unless they REALLY know what they are doing. Certainly more difficult with a Canon mount.

"While balance" - I assume this is a typo and means "white balance" -

WB in RAW is metadata; can be changed any time in post. Someone will have to explain to me why this effects focus or noise in a well exposed image. :huh:

Yes, it's all in metadata and can be changed in post. But, I saw a thread recently that seemed to indicate it was useful for other reasons, to do it while shooting. I can't find they post, only a bookmark'ed post that Graeme prefers to white balance off a neutral grey card to not pick up reflected light.

So, maybe someone can chime in as to whether it's desirable at all? Maybe it affects whether you can see that you are clipping in a channel or somehow affects RED's displays so that you can evaluate the image better?

I don't understand how people are getting all this noise. I shot an entire feature in 2009 on a Red One (M not MX), with only a small Tungsten lighting package, and there wasn't a spec of noise in a single shot.

Not everyone is going to shoot in perfect lighting, so some new users, or people who are browsing and trying to learn about the camera might be interested in de-noising.

Tungsten puts out wavelengths that are nosier to Bayer sensors (more red and blue, I'd guess). Unsure why this didn't affect you?

De-bayering will lower the actual resolution and at the same time lower the noise, due to averaging surrounding pixels to interpolate the missing pixels. So, yes - this might result in a noise level that seems perfect to some. I think it would depend on whether you are viewing single frames and also whether viewing at 100% resolution.

Viewing 5K at 4K resolution should result in very low noise, just as outputting 4K at 1080p should result in very noise free images.

For those who output for the web, de-noising at some stage will help a lot with the compression (smaller files).
 
Totally depends on what I'm doing, but for VFX work I use glass filters in front of the camera. If its just a light source I'll sometimes gel them instead or use a diachroic filter on it. Several ways to tackle this depending on your shooting situation.

Thanks Phil. I don't feel so stupid now for asking. Thanks!
 
Why so sarcastic Erich, instead of being helpful. The original post is trying to help. I see you are on your way to become the next pixar. Were you born with all of your knowledge, experience etc? So yes, I'm sure some of us are not sure how to work with our new Scarlet cameras, sure we need to learn, and become better at lighting, exposing etc. But I don't get why is it that some members feel the need to come in to the thread, that is trying to help, and are being sarcastic, or essentially making fun of people that invested in RED, and are trying to learn and become better at the craft.

It's easy: shoot with whatever lighting was there when you arrived on location, with no attempt to bring the dynamic range in front of the camera within the camera's sweet spot (~12 stops) and no attempt to maintain consistent color balance throughout the scene.

Is it really shocking that people who can barely afford a Scarlet also can't afford to properly control the lighting in a scene?
 
I mentioned that as someone had 'focused' by moving their lens to infinity, and they were having some issues with softness. I've seen a few threads where the back focus was off, but ... agreed, no one should try to adjust back focus unless they REALLY know what they are doing. Certainly more difficult with a Canon mount.



Yes, it's all in metadata and can be changed in post. But, I saw a thread recently that seemed to indicate it was useful for other reasons, to do it while shooting. I can't find they post, only a bookmark'ed post that Graeme prefers to white balance off a neutral grey card to not pick up reflected light.

So, maybe someone can chime in as to whether it's desirable at all? Maybe it affects whether you can see that you are clipping in a channel or somehow affects RED's displays so that you can evaluate the image better?



Not everyone is going to shoot in perfect lighting, so some new users, or people who are browsing and trying to learn about the camera might be interested in de-noising.

Tungsten puts out wavelengths that are nosier to Bayer sensors (more red and blue, I'd guess). Unsure why this didn't affect you?

De-bayering will lower the actual resolution and at the same time lower the noise, due to averaging surrounding pixels to interpolate the missing pixels. So, yes - this might result in a noise level that seems perfect to some. I think it would depend on whether you are viewing single frames and also whether viewing at 100% resolution.

Viewing 5K at 4K resolution should result in very low noise, just as outputting 4K at 1080p should result in very noise free images.

For those who output for the web, de-noising at some stage will help a lot with the compression (smaller files).


Les - again, with all due respect to your efforts, your comments are not very scientific or helpful when it comes down to what's going to make a difference.

Like all electronic sensors, the RED MX is going to be more sensitive to the green-blue spectrum and, therefore, doesn't do as well in tungsten lighting. This is a known fact but your white balance while shooting will not effect what you end up with. Phil Holland suggested effectively "changing" your lighting to 5000-5600K but I am not sure the way you present this issue on your "checklist" will be all that helpful. Again, there is no substitute for good exposure when it come to noise. As far as focus, there is no way to "fix" focus - you just have to get it nailed using all the tools you have. When you do - it's there.

You make reference to threads where REDusers are claiming various phenomena, but there is no evidence that these occurrences are attributable to any genuine problems. As to white balancing with a grey card - you can white balance with anything that has equal parts red-green-blue; grey is less reflective than white but they all have the same effect if done correctly. Again - just not relevant to the noise issue or needed on a checklist of things to do to eliminate noise and focus "softness."

I appreciate what you are trying to do. My problem with the way you did it is that it really distracts from what people should be paying attention to to get good exposures. I suggest looking for some old posts where Jim gives his own formulas for getting good results in terms of exposure.As for focus... just make sure you have good eyes, use your tools and don't expect more out of your lenses than they are capable of. :smiley:

As for the point about shooting at 800, but 320 if you have a light meter... ?? :huh:
 
White Balance will never effect your focus. However it could effect your noise as the native color temperature of the Mysterium X is 5000 Kelvin. I do my best to shoot at 5000-5600k and use filtration when shooting tungsten to bring the color temperature up most of the time. You dont have to mind you, as you can correct this later and still get great results.

Very useful! I modified my original post to include this, and will do so for other some other comments. Let me know if my language doesn't um up your post.
 
Back
Top