Misha Engel
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jun 12, 2017
- Messages
- 1,849
- Reaction score
- 1
- Points
- 0
Misha,
I don't like how the footage blows out the highlights in some instances. However, from the comparisons against the 4K version, I think it does a better job of retaining more highlight detail. The "highlight recovery" function in the Blackmagic Raw tab in Resolve, IMHO, seems to be not that useful. The skin tones and some lighting scenarios seem to push more toward green but can be as easily corrected as the greenish bias in the red Helium, Monstro or Gemini. Also, I like the Raw controls for Blackmagic Raw(.Braw) and their effectiveness on the .Braw files.
The colors seem okay for coming from a 12-bit Raw file but I think the 'Komodo" will hopefully have atleast some form of 16-bit or maybe a 14-bit Redcode Raw capabilities.
Still playing around with some sample footage , so still just examining things.
I think that all Raw files from current cinema camera's are logged to 12 bits with X-OCN being the exeption(they claim it's 16 bit linear).
It's not the file, so it must be the sensor which is probably 12 bits.
It's hard to beat ARRI on color, with it's dual 14 bits sensor output(delivering 16 bit ARRIRAW logged to 12 bits).
BRAW on the UMP G2 comes from a dual 11 bits sensor and is pretty good(not ARRI good, but who is?) and easy to match with ARRI except on the highlighs(but who is?).
To bad the best grading panels in the world that are commercially available only have 10 bit panels to judge a 12..16 bit file output.