Karim D. Ghantous
Well-known member
This is a difficult question - more difficult than actually working! Based on 8-perf 35mm, I would probably choose 50mm (~35mm for S35), even though 35mm or 40mm are probably more useful overall. 50mm suits portraiture more, making it a better choice for photography. 35mm is a bit more flexible and many photographers consider it the perfect 'standard' lens.
Maybe for cinema, the slightly wider lens, like 25mm on S35, is more useful - even when doing close-ups (but not extreme ones). It works really well for upper-body close-ups, because you have the sense of immediacy (I'm thinking of the opening shot in Pulp Fiction, which was probably done with a 25mm, or some shots in Downton Abbey). And it lets you do medium shots without having to move too far back. Also, you get more DOF without needing to stop down as much.
But I don't think that I could work with just one lens. Perhaps I could shoot any script with just two lenses - an 18mm and a 35mm (S35). For photography, though, I want 8-perf focal lengths from 28mm all the way to 200mm (~18-135mm in S35).
Maybe for cinema, the slightly wider lens, like 25mm on S35, is more useful - even when doing close-ups (but not extreme ones). It works really well for upper-body close-ups, because you have the sense of immediacy (I'm thinking of the opening shot in Pulp Fiction, which was probably done with a 25mm, or some shots in Downton Abbey). And it lets you do medium shots without having to move too far back. Also, you get more DOF without needing to stop down as much.
But I don't think that I could work with just one lens. Perhaps I could shoot any script with just two lenses - an 18mm and a 35mm (S35). For photography, though, I want 8-perf focal lengths from 28mm all the way to 200mm (~18-135mm in S35).