Mark K.
Well-known member
Erich, maybe it was lost in my post but I'm wasn't evaluating strengths and weaknesses of each lens set, as they both have strengths and weaknesses. So while a Celere is 1.75 stops faster, (which can be a great use for those who need the speed,) my comments were exclusively in the context of how well they could match the look of S4's.
The poster I was replying to was wondering if Celere with emulated 'cooke' color matched coatings could be integrated into a set of Cooke S4 lenses and match. If using the lenses for a purpose in that context, I made the point that I thought it was a wasted effort to make the Celere's integrate into a set of Cooke S4's versus using the already available Mini S4's because no matter how well they manage to emulate Cooke, it won't be a better match.
However, people use mismatched lenses all the time and if you select carefully, shoot in a way to hide the differences and do some extra post work, most things can look like something else when used sparsely or well. The point is, if matching S4's with a budget set of lenses is the goal and you're not using Mini S4's, your priorities are things other than matching S4's.
That said, my intention was not to rip on the Celere lenses. I feel the Celere lenses definitely have their useful place in the world of budget cinema lenses and I commend the creators of the lenses on their interesting approach with such positive results. We should definitely celebrate the fun options of different lens coatings and the creative choices they offer. That's the real goodness.
A bigger deal than matching in with the Cooke Look (IMO), is the fact that the Celeres share the same coatings as Angenieux (it's the same supplier), so it's quite possible that they'll cut in with Optimo zooms much more seamlessly than Cooke or Zeiss primes will.
Personally, I'm just excited that (once the 18.5mm joins the set) we'll have a set of Superspeeds that can be rented for the same sort of price as a set of CP.2s! That's a big deal when you're faced with lighting night exteriors on a budget.