Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

Should i get a GH4 or 5D Mark 3?

Neil Dearman

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 2, 2012
Messages
1,127
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Atlanta/Nashville
Website
neildearman.com
I am in the market of getting a new b camera and want to know which one I should get. I am more comfortable with Canon (used 7D/5D all the time) but never have laid my hands on Panasonic DSLR. What should I do please let me know thanks!!!
 
5D Mark III as you know only shoots 1080. You can hack it for RAW 1080 capabilities, thought I think your money is better well spent on another camera. Wait until NAB to see what breeds arise. The GH4 does look promising. Can't wait to see more footage.
 
I agree about waiting for NAB, but as a B-Cam I'd say the Blackmagic Production Camera would be the best option at the moment.

Unless you need it for still too...
 
I have a GH4 with me for a few weeks. Its a pretty fun camera.

The 4K is not bad, and the 1080P slomo option is great. Albeit annoying for us PAL guys that it only goes to 96fps.

I have the YAGH too, but no odyssey to record to :(
 
I am in the market of getting a new b camera and want to know which one I should get. I am more comfortable with Canon (used 7D/5D all the time) but never have laid my hands on Panasonic DSLR. What should I do please let me know thanks!!!

What are your "B" lenses? If all you have is EF glass, the Panasonic is going to cost you a lot more than a 5D3. There just is not yet a sensible way to put EF glass on a m43 mount, let alone dealing with the crop factor. That said, if you happen to already own a lot of m43 glass (like I do), the GH4 looks like a super "B" camera, and I plan to buy one or two as such.

I will second the notion that a Blackmagic also makes a terrific B camera. Of course it has a substantial crop factor compared with FF (or even RED's concept of FF), but after doing some pretty extensive comparisons between DRAGON and BMCC (haven't tried BM4K), the BMCC is really pretty amazing. And shooting RAW will make it that much easier to get your gamma and color matrices to agree. I am eager to see what starting points the GH4 offers.
 
I am in the market of getting a new b camera and want to know which one I should get. I am more comfortable with Canon (used 7D/5D all the time) but never have laid my hands on Panasonic DSLR. What should I do please let me know thanks!!!

The answer would depend on your priorities.

If you have to go with stills camera for video (instead of C100 for example) and priority is motion imaging quality, GH4 is superior.
5D marketed resolution refers only to a container containing mush.
 
using 5d 3 raw as b cam to my epic….don't know about the gh4 yet
 
I'm using a Blackmagic Pocket as a B-cam, and a 5D3 as A C-cam. The pocket is just better out of the box, and its small size makes it really intriguing and fun to use. On the other hand the 5D3 is great with the Magic Lantern add-on (which from my personal experience runs very smoothly, and now includes the new firmware as well, using three Komputerbay 64GB x1000 CF cards), I shot a short film in June with it, and I'm still amazed by its overall quality -compared to its original image- :) I also had the chance to play with the GH4 at BVE, and I'm seriously thinking of replacing the 5D3 with it, but I'll have to check how it performs photo-wise since I use the 5D3 for stills, a lot. I'd say that if you can wait, just wait. Otherwise, the 5D3 won't lose much value if you decide to resell it in june/july & on the other hand the pocket might impress you for its size. This article was fun to read, might help you out http://library.creativecow.net/kaufman_debra/Behind-the-Lens-Rodney-Charters/1
 
thanks guys so I have a ton of Canon Glass if I get the GH4 am I SOL?
 
thanks guys so I have a ton of Canon Glass if I get the GH4 am I SOL?

As far as I know, yes. There are a few "dumb" converters that will physically mate an EF lens to a m43 body. But there's no aperture control, and in some cases (like the 85 f1.2L), no focus control, either.

If all you want to do is to put your Canon glass to work, look at a BMCC with EF mount. Or look at a Scarlett with an EF mount. If you specifically need a camera that's tiny (to get into spaces you cannot with a properly kitted RED), then the GH4 will beat the 5D, and the Blackmagic Pocket Camera will beat the GH4. See this cool article: http://library.creativecow.net/kaufman_debra/Behind-the-Lens-Rodney-Charters/1

As always, the better you can define the problem you are trying to solve, the better your solution can ultimately be.
 
thanks guys so I have a ton of Canon Glass if I get the GH4 am I SOL?

Canon has the best options for you. Once the new cameras are announced at NAB and other events, people will be selling their gear to get money for upgrades and the 5D3 is nearing it's replacement date.
 
well since you have canon glass, and if you are ready to go now, then youd probably be better off with a eos mounted camera, either a 5D, or c100, or BMCC…but if you can wait for NAB then i would wait.
 
They are different tools and each has areas where it shines.

We have a 5DmkIII and use it when needed. We also have a GH4 on order and look forward to putting it through its paces.
 
I'd wait till after NAB if there's no rush. Never know what's coming out. Maybe nothing but still, wait if you can.
 
well I bought a 60D ($600 for the body Fumfie.com) cause I needed it for my shoot in LA next week. I have a 7D too that I am bringing with me just have a multi camera shoot. But most likely if canon doesnt' come out with anything big will get a 5D Mark 3.
 
I'd wait till after NAB if there's no rush. Never know what's coming out. Maybe nothing but still, wait if you can.

Latest info says that Canon is going to drop a 4K equivalent to the 5D - not a 5D4 but a new camera line that will eventually replace the 5D series - in the near future as well as new 4K video cameras and a bunch of hybrid video/still EOS lenses.
 
For what its worth, Im really enjoying the GH4. Im not primarily looking at it as a B camera for my epic, but more as a replacement/complimentary camera for my 5D3 type jobs (events etc) and for travel.

The low light on the 5D3 is what keeps me using it, and whilst the GH4 isn't quite there its still good, especially after some neat video so I will probably keep both.

The file size of the 4K from the GH4 is so small (around 10MB per second) it makes shooting 4K for a 1080P finish on smaller (or web) jobs less of a question. Plus having the high speed really helps. (just wish it did 100fps over 96)

The weather here has been super shitty (believe it or not) but hopefully will be able to get out and shoot some stuff this weekend to post.

I see no reason why, for the price, people shouldn't have one of these in their bag. I just sold off my pocket cameras, they just weren't doing it for me, but this is the "little" camera that I needed. The look is obviously more video-y, and the DR isn't as good as the blackmagic but those might get better if this gets hacked like the previous cams and the things I hated about the pocket, huge file size and crappy battery times are the opposite on the GH4. The other plus is it takes pretty good stills.

Only thing that carries over is the need for high end cards. Ive been supplied the new panasonic U3 SD cards, but the sandisk 95s seem to work just as well so far.

Lets see what canon bring out at NAB but I think unless they hit the nail directly on the head so to speak, panasonic is going to sell a lot of GH4s.
 
Back
Top