Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

Food for thought?

Jason Comparetto

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 2, 2008
Messages
1,979
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
43
Location
Anywhere planes fly
Website
www.cinemaoxide.com
It occurred to me today to draw an analogy between the video camera business and the car industry, and the analogy could easily be applied to any of the industries out there that we see making very small incremental changes in their products.

Jim Jannard's vision combined with perseverance to see it through to completion resulted in a GIGANTIC LEAP, a dramatic change in how movies could be shot, both in Hollywood for theatrical release and also for small productions. If we had left it up to Sony or Canon, you know we'd still be shooting in 1080p in the year 2013. Yea the images would have been sharper, the sensors would be larger, but at the end of the day 1080p would have been "good enough" for these big players in the camera business. " 4K " might not even be a term yet

I wonder if some of the big players in the car industry (Toyota, Honda, GM, Ford) are again simply making small incremental changes. Every year one company is able to make a small incremental change and then all the others have to catch up slightly. This cycle continues for 20 years, and we are left with cars that still burn more fuel than a long time ago. It kind of reminds me of that old 1080p sensor. Could cars be made to get 80 miles/gallon? 160 miles/gallon? Get rid of gallons all together?

What if someone comes along willing to change the status quo. The project might take them 10 years. It might cost a billion dollars, but the passion will see that person through thick and thin. Jim has proven that you don't have to be a gigantic corporation to change an entire industry. I'm sure Jim was told by so many people that his idea was "crazy".

Perhaps I'm over-simplifying an engineering problem, but what if I'm not? After all, I'm sure Jim was told many times that making a 4K camera was "impossible", or "too expensive", or "what do you know about making cameras?"

Next thing you know its very POSSIBLE, its very INEXPENSIVE, and then you find out that the man knows ALOT about making cameras.

I hope Jim's passion can inspire some future generation of inventors and innovators to not be afraid to think far into the future, and realize that the DISTANT future could be the NEAR future if they can apply themselves.
 
Tesla might be on that road, Jason. They can't yet do it inexpensively but they are doing it differently.
 
It occurred to me today to draw an analogy between the video camera business and the car industry, and the analogy could easily be applied to any of the industries out there that we see making very small incremental changes in their products.

Jim Jannard's vision combined with perseverance to see it through to completion resulted in a GIGANTIC LEAP, a dramatic change in how movies could be shot, both in Hollywood for theatrical release and also for small productions. If we had left it up to Sony or Canon, you know we'd still be shooting in 1080p in the year 2013. Yea the images would have been sharper, the sensors would be larger, but at the end of the day 1080p would have been "good enough" for these big players in the camera business. " 4K " might not even be a term yet

I wonder if some of the big players in the car industry (Toyota, Honda, GM, Ford) are again simply making small incremental changes. Every year one company is able to make a small incremental change and then all the others have to catch up slightly. This cycle continues for 20 years, and we are left with cars that still burn more fuel than a long time ago. It kind of reminds me of that old 1080p sensor. Could cars be made to get 80 miles/gallon? 160 miles/gallon? Get rid of gallons all together?

What if someone comes along willing to change the status quo. The project might take them 10 years. It might cost a billion dollars, but the passion will see that person through thick and thin. Jim has proven that you don't have to be a gigantic corporation to change an entire industry. I'm sure Jim was told by so many people that his idea was "crazy".

Perhaps I'm over-simplifying an engineering problem, but what if I'm not? After all, I'm sure Jim was told many times that making a 4K camera was "impossible", or "too expensive", or "what do you know about making cameras?"

Next thing you know its very POSSIBLE, its very INEXPENSIVE, and then you find out that the man knows ALOT about making cameras.

I hope Jim's passion can inspire some future generation of inventors and innovators to not be afraid to think far into the future, and realize that the DISTANT future could be the NEAR future if they can apply themselves.

There is an underlying assumption here of "good will" in that Government and Industry are actually interested in people's welfare and not their own profit and power, God is dead and Man is all powerful compared to the forces of nature. Having a good deal of experience in the auto industry, it's mostly based on marketing for short term gain, not true humanitarian interest...

Many are abusing the "Green Movement" for Profit or CONTROL over people. Pick your poison. The ultimate solution
is do your best with your resources and try not to be abusive to people or the environment.

Quite honestly, the most green thing for the Earth that could happen, would be humans go the path of the dinosaur...

I'll let the sage give the closing sermon:
George Carlin on The Environment



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjmtSkl53h4

RIP George Carlin
 
It occurred to me today to draw an analogy between the video camera business and the car industry, and the analogy could easily be applied to any of the industries out there that we see making very small incremental changes in their products.

Jim Jannard's vision combined with perseverance to see it through to completion resulted in a GIGANTIC LEAP, a dramatic change in how movies could be shot, both in Hollywood for theatrical release and also for small productions. If we had left it up to Sony or Canon, you know we'd still be shooting in 1080p in the year 2013. Yea the images would have been sharper, the sensors would be larger, but at the end of the day 1080p would have been "good enough" for these big players in the camera business. " 4K " might not even be a term yet

I wonder if some of the big players in the car industry (Toyota, Honda, GM, Ford) are again simply making small incremental changes. Every year one company is able to make a small incremental change and then all the others have to catch up slightly. This cycle continues for 20 years, and we are left with cars that still burn more fuel than a long time ago. It kind of reminds me of that old 1080p sensor. Could cars be made to get 80 miles/gallon? 160 miles/gallon? Get rid of gallons all together?

What if someone comes along willing to change the status quo. The project might take them 10 years. It might cost a billion dollars, but the passion will see that person through thick and thin. Jim has proven that you don't have to be a gigantic corporation to change an entire industry. I'm sure Jim was told by so many people that his idea was "crazy".

Perhaps I'm over-simplifying an engineering problem, but what if I'm not? After all, I'm sure Jim was told many times that making a 4K camera was "impossible", or "too expensive", or "what do you know about making cameras?"

Next thing you know its very POSSIBLE, its very INEXPENSIVE, and then you find out that the man knows ALOT about making cameras.

I hope Jim's passion can inspire some future generation of inventors and innovators to not be afraid to think far into the future, and realize that the DISTANT future could be the NEAR future if they can apply themselves.

Watch the documentary "WHat ever happened to the Electric Car? They've had the tech for a long time, now they are releasing it - there's the Volt and others. Why it took so long I have no idea, but I would guess there are a few strange men behind a few curtains.
 
I am with John Bellari here.
Going back tot he automobile analogy, this great film immediately came to mind:
"Tucker: The Man and His Dream" (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0096316/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1)
which is a sad testament of how most of the times the industry will probably fuck you up if you dare challenge their status quo. Fortunately, this did not happen with Mr. Jannard and the entire RED team. To me, RED in this respect is simply a miracle (wonderful btw).
 
I think another thing that may be very pertinent to your thoughts about the difference between incremental improvement and industry-shifting, paradigm shifting progress would be to read about disruption theory. If you're interested in Apple at all I can point you towards a fascinating podcast that discusses Apple through the lens of disruptive theory, the entire subject is immensely interesting and does apply to many many industries (The podcast is called "The Critical Path" from the 5by5 network.) Also : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disruptive_innovation

He (Horace Dediu, the host of the Critical Path) also specifically covers the automobile industry on a few episodes, and went on to spin-off a second podcast called Asymcar which you may also find interesting :)

:)
Medfa
 
Last edited:
There is an underlying assumption here of "good will" in that Government and Industry are actually interested in people's welfare and not their own profit and power, God is dead and Man is all powerful compared to the forces of nature. Having a good deal of experience in the auto industry, it's mostly based on marketing for short term gain, not true humanitarian interest...

Many are abusing the "Green Movement" for Profit or CONTROL over people. Pick your poison. The ultimate solution
is do your best with your resources and try not to be abusive to people or the environment.

Quite honestly, the most green thing for the Earth that could happen, would be humans go the path of the dinosaur...

I'll let the sage give the closing sermon:
George Carlin on The Environment



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjmtSkl53h4

RIP George Carlin

/signed
 
Back
Top