Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

Drone Pilots: FAA exemptions?

jake southard

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 29, 2014
Messages
705
Reaction score
9
Points
18
Location
Beverly Hills, CA
Website
www.jakesouthard.net
Are there any drone pilots out there who have done anything with the FAA regarding flying their drone?
I'm sick of getting yelled at every time I take my little Inspire One into the air.
Random people even... they will come up and threaten arrest for no reason while i'm flying.. Or call the police. Last time I checked, i'm doing nothing wrong. Seeing as how the drone "rules" fluctuate so drastically, i'm wondering if anyone here has applied for anything like an FAA exemption under section 333?

And how hard it is to obtain... I read something online today and have submitted a request within the last 10 minutes, we will see if I even did it right...
https://www.faa.gov/uas/legislative_programs/section_333/how_to_file_a_petition/
I essentially just explained who I was, what I have (dji inspire one), and what I do. and asked for a blanket exemption to be able to fly under 200 feet, under 54 pounds, and within line of sight, wherever I want. (except near airports and Washington DC).
 
Somewhat of a bad question today. Since 5 drones forced the grounding of all the firefighting aircraft at the I-15 fire 2 days ago there are probably going to be new rules and fines.

In the meantime 500 FAA exemptions have been given for commercial drone use as of 2 weeks ago. At the moment to get an FAA exemption the pilot must have at least a FAA recreational pilot certificate.I am not sure how many of those exemptions are for commercial filming companies. I just worked with a company with an exemption in Hawaii.

For non commercial uses no license is required at the moment. Just common sense.
 
Automatic exemption as long as you follow these rules:

"As of March 23, 2015, the FAA will automatically grant a "blanket" COA for flights at or below 200 feet to any UAS operator with a Section 333 exemption, provided the aircraft weighs less than 55 pounds, operations are conducted during daytime Visual Flight Rules (VFR) conditions and within visual line of sight (VLOS) of the pilots, and stay certain distances away from airports or heliports. " - https://www.faa.gov/uas/legislative_programs/section_333/how_to_file_a_petition/

Information on how to file a petition for exemption is here. Basically you have to explain why you want an exemption and from what sections and how far you'll exceed those sections why the exemption won't adversely affect public safety etc.
 
It's a lot of paperwork, the 333 exemption is only the first part, still need ops manual and a few other things. Most of the early people spent $30k to get it done. Now you can get a 333 done for $2500 not including pilot training if required.

It's taking about 90 days right now to get your 333.

A UAV certificate will stop most people and cops from hassling you which you can get for $200
 
Aaron- do you have a link handy on how/where to get the UAV cert? Thanks!
 
Are there any drone pilots out there who have done anything with the FAA regarding flying their drone?
I'm sick of getting yelled at every time I take my little Inspire One into the air.
Random people even... they will come up and threaten arrest for no reason while i'm flying.. Or call the police. Last time I checked, i'm doing nothing wrong. Seeing as how the drone "rules" fluctuate so drastically, i'm wondering if anyone here has applied for anything like an FAA exemption under section 333?

And how hard it is to obtain... I read something online today and have submitted a request within the last 10 minutes, we will see if I even did it right...
https://www.faa.gov/uas/legislative_programs/section_333/how_to_file_a_petition/
I essentially just explained who I was, what I have (dji inspire one), and what I do. and asked for a blanket exemption to be able to fly under 200 feet, under 54 pounds, and within line of sight, wherever I want. (except near airports and Washington DC).

Problem with getting Gov approval for a fundamental right to record anything in public view, as a non-commercial / amateur, is that the Gov can then take it away. Know, then assert your existing rights responsibly without asking "pretty please" to some random authority figure. Just because someone who approaches you is ignorant and outraged doesn't make them right or empowered. Another level of certification does nothing to change the fact that they are aggressive idiots. I'm of course also including those with a gun and a badge. You toss out that your are FAA Licensed when they have it in their mind to ruin your day - then you have given them one more avenue to do so.

As far as all the hyperbole about drones causing Heli's to be grounded - Heli pilots want all drones to die and go away since it is a direct threat to their career. Consider the source of any criticism and what their personal agenda is. I mean really, you're fighting a fire and you see a Phantom somehow 600' from you (two football fields away) through the smoke so you ground the entire fleet for the rest of the day? Really? Not sure we would have ever gotten to the moon with that pantie waist attitude. ;-)

Fly smart an know the every changing rules.
 
Last edited:
Problem with getting Gov approval for a fundamental right to record anything in public view, as a non-commercial / amateur, is that the Gov can then take it away. Know, then assert your existing rights responsibly without asking "pretty please" to some random authority figure. Just because someone who approaches you is ignorant and outraged doesn't make them right or empowered. Another level of certification does nothing to change the fact that they are aggressive idiots. I'm of course also including those with a gun and a badge. You toss out that your are FAA Licensed when they have it in their mind to ruin your day - then you have given them one more avenue to do so.

As far as all the hyperbole about drones causing Heli's to be grounded - Heli pilots want all drones to die and go away since it is a direct threat to their career. Consider the source of any criticism and what their personal agenda is. I mean really, you're fighting a fire and you see a Phantom somehow 600' from you (two football fields away) through the smoke so you ground the entire fleet for the rest of the day? Really? Not sure we would have ever gotten to the moon with that pantie waist attitude. ;-)

Fly smart an know the every changing rules.


Very well said...
Seems like the best thing to do upon a threatening individual is to stay calm and explain our rights as an "amateur" to be able to fly anywhere* within line of site. And keep flying of course.
 
You know what takes down fire fighters? Not a bird size plastic drone. Their own management by making the executive decision to use shitty old equipment driven by short sighted budget cutbacks:

 
Zen
Why don't you spend one hour in a Heli fighting a fire and then make your statements.

Crash a few times. Lose a few friends who crash. Lose your front teeth in a crash like I have. Rescue a mountain climbing crew on the Eiger. Then discuss real Heli pilots scared of drones.
 
Zen
Why don't you spend one hour in a Heli fighting a fire and then make your statements.

Crash a few times. Lose a few friends who crash. Lose your front teeth in a crash like I have. Rescue a mountain climbing crew on the Eiger. Then discuss real Heli pilots scared of drones.


You make it a bit difficult to have a even discussion with that emotional intro but I'll give it a go. Please excuse the detour into politics on RU - drones are currently all about that.

Fire fighting is a dangerous business. Flying heli's is a dangerous business. Risk management is always a concern anytime you do something dangerous. The risk a Phantom adds to fire fighting has yet to be fairly calculated. I'm guessing it's in the .000001% range since there has never been an incident other than pilots stating "I saw 5 quad coptors out my windshield and had to take evasive action endangering everyone causing us to ground the entire fleet for the rest of the day!!”.

The News Media (with their $3M “SkyNews 7 Chopper“ sitting idle in the hanger) report these statements as fact with no follow up questions like “how could you see a Phantom 1/4 mile away when flying through smoke and while being fully engaged in the act of flying?” Come on. All commercial Heli pilots have a vested interest in keeping drones out of their business. Reporters used to question the answers - not anymore.

It's manufacturing consent. The AOPA, Heli Owners, Heli Manufacturers and the centralized News Media have huge incentive to keep the status quo. There is no desire to have an unrestricted, non-monetize, democratic flow of user generated news content on an open Internet from the billion dollar business that is Big Media / Big Aviation with the full support of our Big Gov.

They, like I, see drone growth as a huge disruptive force that can shift power away from those with power and control to those without it. It's a basic democratic right to be able to do your own investigative reporting using a drone to fly over, let's say, a huge toxic spill into the Colorado River (last week) or a stockyard where animal cruelty is taking place (ongoing).

States like Texas pass laws restricting individuals from flying over businesses documenting crimes like pouring toxic waste into a stream, while allowing increasingly invasive law enforcement policies . . . including the use of drones that can see through your roof / walls, into your house. It’s our right to lose if we don’t assert that right at every front, including individuals covering a forest fire with a bird sized drone.

Using the “all private drones are a danger to society” is not supported by fact or logic. It is an emotional play to get the public opinion shaped waiting for that 9/11 drone incident - then the FAA will have full public support to pass some jacked up form of the Patriot Act for Drones. We will all then lose yet another civil liberty from a way out of scale response to a single event.

Sorry about your friends and injuries from all the Heli crashes. But our basic civil liberties are more important than any one person’s safety doing a already dangerous job. You as an accomplished Hollywood Artist can look back in history to see how our Gov and Big Biz can use fear to clamp down on perceived threats to their power. Ronald Reagan comes to mind for some reason.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nJzV6-wJ3SQ
 
I just have to say that I'm so fed up with drone politics lately -- all sides of the various arguments. Everywhere around me in parks, open space areas, etc.. we're seeing signs go up saying that the flying of drones or RC or computer controlled toys or other craft is prohibited. On the flip side, I've seen some people do some terribly stupid things with their little quadcopters. I personally lost a DJI Phantom (original version) and have no idea where it landed (or crashed, as the case may be). It went goofy and I lost all communication/control with the Phantom. It decided to fly away from me instead of returning to its home position. Seemed to fly off in a straight line, out of sight. I searched for it or any sign of it for the rest of the day, nearly 8 hours, until dark. If someone found it, they ended up with a GoPro Hero3 (brand new at the time) and a 64GB microSD card.

That said, I own other drones and I of course fly them. I have investments in companies that make drones or related equipment. Had a company that builds drones as a tenant in one of my buildings... It's a booming business right now. And yet, the public at large acts as if they're terrified of drones and we're all going to die. I try to fly mine in places where there are no other people or where I have a direct purpose. Even then, I still have people threaten me, just as Jake has in his original post. I've had cops show up on two occasions after someone complained. One of the instances they were fine and we had a good laugh about the paranoid complainant. The other time the cops were being dicks and wanted to confiscate my drone and camera equipment and issue me a citation -- although they had no idea what sort of citation, hence why they wanted to take my equipment. So I told them I wasn't handing over any of my equipment without a warrant. This was after I had already spent over 30 minutes showing them everything and explaining what I was doing, showing them copies of the current FAA allowances for non-commercial drones and that I was just playing around with it -- flying over a small lake. Yes, I keep printed pages with me with web links. It basically ended with me giving them contact info for my attorney's office and telling them I was leaving as I had better things to do. They never threatened to arrest me, although I suppose that would have ended poorly for them if they took it hat far and I think they knew that.

The current state of drone paranoia is ridiculous. I pretty much don't even want to fly mine anymore unless I'm on my own property where people can't bother me.
 
Jeff, I think we've all had fly aways if we've been doing it for any length of time. I remember those guys who had a fly away on one of the first FAA approved commercial flights in DTLA with a Epic on board that was never located. I still think they are trying to go back to China although I know it's more likely a stuck IMU.

We've had some luck with the above UAV IDs when it comes to not getting hassled after we show it.
 
Morons crashing their drones into people and cause other types of accidents are the ones who dictate the rules of use, not professionals who knows what they do... that's just how it is for any technology.

I see this thread as a continuation of the old one about the same things. There I suggested that professionals need a UAV license and get specific permissions for shooting in populated areas. Nature photography is another thing, but as soon as you start flying heavy gear over civilians you are putting them into danger, whatever you think about "common sense". Flying a chopper isn't the same as a little (relative) UAV which could catch some rouge winds and fly straight into a little kid or something.

I'm all for having the ability to shoot with drones, but I'm not stupid enough to think "common sense" is the only thing you need for safe operations. I've been on a production where the professional "I got 20 years in this business"-pilot flew a 25Kg drone straight through a populated place down into the ocean. If that drone went into an apartment or into a crowd it could definitely have killed someone. That guy gave me enough of the "I got common sense" bullshit, literary.

So am I surprised about all the regulations and rules? No and I think there should be some, but the rules should be based on logic, not authorities scared of people who don't like drones.
 
These are turbulent times for drone operators. With authorization drones have as much rights to the sky as manned aircraft. The only guaranteed way to not get confronted is to only fly where you have permission. In urban areas we only fly under permit to stay out of trouble. No worries if the police are working your closed set. Everybody wants to do things quick and easy but those days are gone now.
 
I agree in that I believe operators of small unmaned aircraft need a permit to fly. Tell me where to get this "permit", and i'll get one. the real problem is that nobody can tell us what to do in order to fly legally. A lot of buzz about the 333 exemption, but good luck getting one. In the end, people's paranoia is blown WAY. WAY. out of proportion. Mostly due to media.

Eventually there will be instruction on what to do and how to do it, but for now, its chaos.
 
By film permit I mean the standard one issued by the Mayor's film office for inner city shooting. If you can cut and paste you can get a section333. It is the only legal Avenue before final rules.
 
The final rule is looking like it will be the same process as it is now as no matter what you need an exemption from all the FAR's that don't apply to drones...an example would be the requirement that all aircraft operating in US airspace have a Pilots Operating Handbook on board which is not practical for UAV's so you will always need to apply for an exemption from that rule and others. The 333 is the easy part, you still need all the other docs to be legal. It's just like getting a FAA Movie Manual, a big hassle but worth it once you have it.

If your operating UAV's commercially right now and not making $1k per day on the low end with a phantom 3 doing inspections in the midwest to $15k per day in the movie biz your doing it wrong.
 
Morons crashing their drones into people and cause other types of accidents are the ones who dictate the rules of use, not professionals who knows what they do... that's just how it is for any technology.

That's the media and aviation industry talking points bullshit. In fact, as long as there has been humans on this planet, those who make the rules are the ones in power.

If the products which actually harmed people were the ones most regulated then there would be no guns, booze and bacon in 'Merica. But those are some real powerful lobbies so we don't even have that discussion.

This whole regulation issue is caused by the friction of change from old brick and mortar aviation / news gathering to the modern method of democratization of technology and information. No one wants to see their career or $3M asset become obsolete so they use "public safety" as a call to action. How many people were injured or killed by RC drones last year? More people choked on hot dogs and died in the single State of Texas on July 4th, 2014 by far.

It's a red herring which vested Big Media, Big Aviation and our control hungry Gov propagates.


Edit:
Let's come at this another way . . . how many boating accidents / deaths were there in the most current year with stats? Go to page 7 of the PDF:
http://www.uscgboating.org/library/accident-statistics/USCGBoatingStatistics2012.pdf

How many States require any form of boating license? Not many (click on "2.7 Mandatory Boat Operator Licensing")
http://uscgboating.org/regulations/state-boating-laws.php

How about a special license for a 75 year old retiree to drive a 45' Greyhound bus size RV while pulling another 20' of trailer . . . which total length exceeds that of most tractor trailers? Nope.
http://changingears.com/rv-sec-state-rv-license.shtml

If the desire was truly to regulate those things that might cause innocent people harm, seems like we would start with the proven killers: Boats, RV's and Guns

Not going to happen since Big Biz is in control of those products. Drone regulation is not about public safety - it's about control of information

BTW: I'm a licensed IFR rated pilot with lots of time in big airplanes flying really high 'n stuff. I get why they regulate airplanes. No idea where the current drone conversation / laws are taking us other than in the Gov regulation overreach weeds.
 
Last edited:
The final rule is looking like it will be the same process as it is now as no matter what you need an exemption from all the FAR's that don't apply to drones...an example would be the requirement that all aircraft operating in US airspace have a Pilots Operating Handbook on board which is not practical for UAV's so you will always need to apply for an exemption from that rule and others. The 333 is the easy part, you still need all the other docs to be legal. It's just like getting a FAA Movie Manual, a big hassle but worth it once you have it.

If your operating UAV's commercially right now and not making $1k per day on the low end with a phantom 3 doing inspections in the midwest to $15k per day in the movie biz your doing it wrong.

That's not exactly correct. The only reason exemption is needed now is there are no UAS specific rules in 14 CFR that directly address them. The proposed part 107 is very different (less restrictive) from the section 333 requirements (if final rules are published as proposed).
 
Back
Top