Canon DSLR vs Red One: Image Comparison

[Joseph Podlesnik]

Am curious to hear assessments on the differences between these two images.
A friend is comparing a shot from a Canon dslr (on the left) to a Red One clip still. The friend thinks the Red image is just darker. To level the playing field a bit more, I lightened the Red image. I'm trying to explain that
not only is the resolution in the Red greater, but so is the gamma, latitude, depth of color and value range (the Red One image looks more dimensional). I suggested that he perhaps pick a different photo, with less flat lighting, so as to create a more apples-to-apples comparison.
What are your thoughts?

 

[Dan Kanes]

This horse has been beaten to death and beyond the grave, however - since I know you are not trolling, please explain to your friend that a test should be done in the same lighting with the same model, preferably same lens at the same time.

"brighter"

To give just one example:

Underexpose a face on both cameras by three stops.
Now, try to correct both images.
What are your results?

 

[Liam Hall]

Mt thoughts: The DSLR makes your skin look younger...

 

[Terry VerHaar]

Yeah, the woman definitely looks older in the picture on the right! :w00t:

 

[Kemalettin Sert]

dslr image looks like taken with iphone

 

[Ryan Fitzgerald]

Hard to compare gamma and color depth on different age, skin, lighting.... maybe you guys should set up a shot together?
-Ryan

 

[Bryce O]

Yea, you can't compare two completely different shots... that doesn't reveal anything at all.

 

[Martin Weiss]

I'll close this thread as it really has no merit comparing two different shots.