Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

Atomos Blade Failed me again and this time it really cost me!!!!!

Neil Dearman

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 2, 2012
Messages
1,127
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Atlanta/Nashville
Website
neildearman.com
I was filming all last week the CMA Music Fest (for my clients) and I had issues non stop!!! I am so frustrated right now it makes me ill!!!! I had 3 SSD drives go bad (brand new) It was a back up for my RED MAGs and the Blade would turn off, not record, not show the media, every 5 secs would get a screen saying your files are corrupted would you like to fix now or later, take like almost 45 secs to switch between screens, and many other issues. At the end of the shoot maybe 1/4 of the footage for back up was on the blade!!! It is less then 4 months old too. What do i need to do, replace the old one or move onto something more reliable? (on a side not never have issues with the Samurai).
 
Hi Neil

We have 2x Samurai and 2x Pix 240's, we've not had any real issues with either (touch wood, I always get nervous saying this stuff) I'm assuming you're using SSD's on the recommended list? I've heard of issues with the Blade.

I hate using HDMI connectors for anything critical, actually come to think about it we don't use HDMI for any recording connectors, just sometimes for monitoring.

Maybe it's time grab a Samurai to replace the Blade? When you think about it, it's pretty cheap insurance. I wish Red would make a 422 recorder that attached to the Red body, even if it still used the SDI out from the camera.

Luckily you had the R3D's.

Good luck

Adrian
 
I still have my Samuria I just like having the better screen with the blade, and yes I have the RED Files so I am good just frustrated that my blade failed me again!!!
 
Okay sent a support ticket and they say its the drives/firmware... I have used and switched over 4 drives (all brand new) and still having issues!!! Has anyone sent their ninja/blade/samuria or anything to them so they can repair or replace the item? Cause I feel like I am getting the shaft right now and not happy how Atomos is treating me!!! Atomos if you are on this board can you do some street justice and help out a supporter/buyer of your products please!!!!
 
Your lucky you had a reply, I have sent 2 complaints regarding parts not working, they never answered so I warn whoever I can not to buy their equipment!.
 
what wasn't working Paul? My Blade has had several issues but my Samurai has never had any major issues
 
I too am extremely suspect now of the Samurai… I lost a complete half day's shoot. One minute checking every take and the files all there, all in a proper list structure, next second drive completely blank. Unrecoverable.
Atomos said it was most likely the SSD Drive (which was on their recommended list) however my colleague has had it happen to him twice, and another colleague has had it happen to him. If someone told me they have some serious motherboard bug
that ZAPS data randomly like a spinning lotto draw, I would believe them. ATOMOS's suggested solution was to daisy chain Ninjas and Samurais together thus record on multiple devices at once. I presume Sony, Canon and RED suggest buying three cameras and
daisy chaining them together too just in case.

Could have been just unfortunate coincidence, bad SSDs all round with everyone I know, nevertheless, just reporting what happened and how I feel. Never had a piece of equipment catastrophically fail like that on me ever, so understandably skittish with them from here on.
 
Ditto-feel your pain!

Ditto-feel your pain!

I was filming all last week the CMA Music Fest (for my clients) and I had issues non stop!!! I am so frustrated right now it makes me ill!!!! I had 3 SSD drives go bad (brand new) It was a back up for my RED MAGs and the Blade would turn off, not record, not show the media, every 5 secs would get a screen saying your files are corrupted would you like to fix now or later, take like almost 45 secs to switch between screens, and many other issues. At the end of the shoot maybe 1/4 of the footage for back up was on the blade!!! It is less then 4 months old too. What do i need to do, replace the old one or move onto something more reliable? (on a side not never have issues with the Samurai).

Had nothing but trouble with the blade on a recent shoot I have a pix240 myself and it is pretty well bullet proof. You issues sound very familiar.
The red SSD media is without question awesome. I just shot 70 128gig cards through my epic in 30 days without a glitch. The pix was spot on too, can't say the same for the blade on the 'B' camera though.
Cheers
W
 
Hi Neil

We have 2x Samurai and 2x Pix 240's, we've not had any real issues with either (touch wood, I always get nervous saying this stuff) I'm assuming you're using SSD's on the recommended list? I've heard of issues with the Blade.

I hate using HDMI connectors for anything critical, actually come to think about it we don't use HDMI for any recording connectors, just sometimes for monitoring.

Maybe it's time grab a Samurai to replace the Blade? When you think about it, it's pretty cheap insurance. I wish Red would make a 422 recorder that attached to the Red body, even if it still used the SDI out from the camera.

Luckily you had the R3D's.

Good luck

Adrian

I agree, HDMI was never designed for Pro video, its an interface for plugging into your TV and haven't it sit there all day. I normally use SDI whenever I can or HDMI locking cables.

-Brooke | atomos.com
 
I too am extremely suspect now of the Samurai… I lost a complete half day's shoot. One minute checking every take and the files all there, all in a proper list structure, next second drive completely blank. Unrecoverable.
Atomos said it was most likely the SSD Drive (which was on their recommended list) however my colleague has had it happen to him twice, and another colleague has had it happen to him. If someone told me they have some serious motherboard bug
that ZAPS data randomly like a spinning lotto draw, I would believe them. ATOMOS's suggested solution was to daisy chain Ninjas and Samurais together thus record on multiple devices at once. I presume Sony, Canon and RED suggest buying three cameras and
daisy chaining them together too just in case.

Could have been just unfortunate coincidence, bad SSDs all round with everyone I know, nevertheless, just reporting what happened and how I feel. Never had a piece of equipment catastrophically fail like that on me ever, so understandably skittish with them from here on.


Hello Mr Warren,

I normally use SanDisk, and never had an issue. I'd had issues with other brands however. The trouble is that you can get a batch of drives that are poorly made and it seems like media manufactures don't care as much as they once did because they can pump them out.

I recommend always formatting before a shoot as I have mentioned in the past.

Cheers!
-Brooke | atomos.com
 
pix 240i or cd odyssey?

please choose and tell me why.

Thanks!!!!

Between those two:

Pix - better sound, smaller,
Odyssey - better screen, larger

You choose. :)
 
could this be an issue with the SSd drives itself that you were using and not the Blade ? I never had any issues with mien in the past but I noticed its important to use the manufacturer recommended SSD types.
SSD drives in general are not necessarily as reliable as regular spinning drives either...I learned that the hard way while on vacation in Europe when my computers OWC SSD system drive died form one second to the other...literally.
 
Back
Top