debayer test

[Andrae Palmer]

cyan: https://files.me.com/trancepriest/85657h

yellow: https://files.me.com/trancepriest/nfj2o7

magenta: https://files.me.com/trancepriest/0erwso

Here are three files debayered in Davinci Resolve 7.1 at "Quarter Res. Good", "Half Res. Good" and "Full Res. Premium". Files were exported to Tiff RGB 16 bits and are 12 MB each.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Ok so we've had 35 people respond to this test:

Twelve thought it was:
Yellow - Full Res. Premium
Cyan - Half Res. Good
Magenta - Quarter Res. Good


One person thought it was:
Yellow - Full Res. Premium
Cyan - Half Res. Good
Magenta - Quarter Res. Good

One person thought it was:
Yellow - Full Res. Premium
Magenta - Half Res. Good
Cyan - Quarter Res. Good

Twenty one thought it was:
Cyan - Full Res. Premium
Yellow - Half Res. Good
Magenta - Quarter Res. Good

----------------------------------------------------------------

The True Answer is:
Cyan - Full Res. Premium
Yellow - Half Res. Good
Magenta - Quarter Res. Good

 

[Thor Melsted]

OK, I'll go first.

Magenta is quarter, Cyan is half, Yellow is full.

 

[David Rasberry]

Magenta 1/4
Yellow 1/2
Cyan full

They all look really good for 1080p though.
Yellow looks sharpest at full screen, but that seems to be because the detail is a bit coarse compared to the Cyan. Had to go to 800% enlarged on a 22" monitor to decide which was which between those two.

 

[luigivaltulini]

CIao ANdrae,
ok
for me this:

Magenta --> QUARTER
Yellow --> HALF
Cyan --> FULL

Cyan using various filters behave much better off without loss of quality

 

[Jamison Stark]

M = 1/4
Y = 1/2
C = 1/1

 

[Robert Frank]

Yellow= full
Cyan= half
Magenta= quarter

 

[Richard Foster]

Agreed:

Yellow= full
Cyan= half
Magenta= quarter

 

[Mike Van Laanen]

I also agree with the general concensus:

Y = F
C = H
M = Q

Look forward to the visit. Will call after I get in.

 

[Tim Whitcomb]

Ill do some on the PABLO tomorrow WITH and WITHOUT the RED ROCKET.

meantime using the unscientific zoom in and check Forehead skin detail.

Y-F
C- 1/2
M- 1/4

 

[Tim Whitcomb]

Someone should also ping Michael Cioni at LightIron because he did this already

 

[Frank Cueto]

throwing my hat in.

Magenta 1/4
Yellow 1/2
Cyan Full

 

[Greg McDonald]

Magenta - Quarter
Yellow - Half
Cyan - Full

 

[Dustin Cross]

Cyan = full
Yellow - half



Dusty

 

[Frank Cueto]

Comment removed per request of the OP.

 

[Kevin Marshall]

put me down for

Cyan - full
Yellow - half
Magenta - quarter

 

[Matt W.]

throwing my hat in.

Magenta 1/4
Yellow 1/2
Cyan Full

Definitely this.

 

[Ahmad Muswanto]

magenta=1/4
cyan=1/2
yellow=full

 

[Michael Cioni]

All about the low frequency
1.Yellow
2.Cyan
3.Magenta

 

[Christian Edwards]

Y = 1/1
C = 1/2
M = 1/4

 

[Peace Villow]

Cyan: full res premium
yellow: half res good
magenta: quarter res good