Obviously that's what you'd do if you are feeding the monitor from your PC. I was speaking to the trouble Andrew(Hyperfocal) reported with a blu-ray player, or for those thinking of feeding HD-sdi to the HDMI port via a converter box of some sort.
The blu-ray player is probably sending YCbCr, and a HD-sdi signal that is YCbCr and just media converted (rather than colour-format converted) will not be accurate on the Dreamcolour. - as an example, the Blackmagic mini-converter that converts HD-sdi to HDMI is 10-bit, BUT it just media-converts - so you have HD-sdi YCbCr in -> HDMI YCbCr out. So the monitor won't scale that to 709 or DCI or whatever since it isn't RGB.
I imagine that the monitor's internal DSP can't do the heavy-lifting of both colourspace and colourformat conversion, and that's why we have this limitation. Of course, HP could always surprise with a new firmware release, but I wouldn't hold my breath.
Cheers,
Ben Gervais
Digital Imaging Engineer / Freelance, Toronto
c 416-951-1980
h 416-789-9778
bengervais@gmail.com
The blu-ray player is probably sending YCbCr, and a HD-sdi signal that is YCbCr and just media converted (rather than colour-format converted) will not be accurate on the Dreamcolour. - as an example, the Blackmagic mini-converter that converts HD-sdi to HDMI is 10-bit, BUT it just media-converts - so you have HD-sdi YCbCr in -> HDMI YCbCr out. So the monitor won't scale that to 709 or DCI or whatever since it isn't RGB.
I imagine that the monitor's internal DSP can't do the heavy-lifting of both colourspace and colourformat conversion, and that's why we have this limitation. Of course, HP could always surprise with a new firmware release, but I wouldn't hold my breath.
Cheers,
Ben Gervais
Digital Imaging Engineer / Freelance, Toronto
c 416-951-1980
h 416-789-9778
bengervais@gmail.com