Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

  • Hey all, just changed over the backend after 15 years I figured time to give it a bit of an update, its probably gonna be a bit weird for most of you and i am sure there is a few bugs to work out but it should kinda work the same as before... hopefully :)

Back in Tokyo after visiting disaster area

Paul Leeming

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 29, 2006
Messages
2,360
Reaction score
3
Points
38
Location
Osaka, Japan
Website
www.visceralpsyche.com
Hi all,

I've been on the road for the last week and a half, travelling with an Australian TV news crew to Fukushima prefecture and documenting the disaster first-hand.

Let me say this - the scale of the devastation is astonishing and humbling. Cars and boats on top of houses, whole communities wiped literally off the face of the earth.... untold numbers of dead and missing which will only climb over the next weeks and possibly even months.

Whilst in Iwaki city I also experienced a tsunami warning which caused us to hastily retreat to an evacuation centre, though it turned out to be a false alarm in that case luckily.

On top of that people have been nervous about the nuclear reactors sending radioactive steam into the environment.

At one point we were hurriedly ushered into the evacuation centre by hazmat suited officials. I think it was when the number 3 reactor blew it's outer casing? In the absence of immediate information it was hard to work out.

I took my 5D with me on the trip but unfortunately, due to doing the driving, I didn't get many photos of the devastation (we shot from the van and didn't stop, as the roads were narrow and we didn't want to block traffic). I can tell you it's an eerie sight to drive past cars stacked on top of one another just off the road on one side, whilst having a beautiful view of the Pacific ocean on the other. So incongruous that such an idyllic location could have had such violence visited on it by mother nature.

What I've drawn most from being up there are a few things I wanted to note:

1. The Japanese are the most calm, orderly and stoic people I have ever had the pleasure to be among. No looting, no riots, no complaining.... just a determination to get on with fixing the devastation and rebuilding their lives. It's an honour to live here and be a part of that.

2. The Japanese government has been ridiculously slow and inefficient at getting mobilised and getting aid to those who need it up north. We were allowed onto the freeway heading south back to Tokyo as we were a media car, and I was angered to see NO TRUCKS or other aid vehicles heading in the opposite direction, FIVE DAYS AFTER the tsunami had hit. The highway was literally empty. Were I in charge, I'd have seconded 30% of all trucks and buses nationwide to immediately ferry supplies up north from Tokyo to Fukushima and Miyagi prefectures. Many locals have complained about the same thing. It's disgusting and unfortunately shows up one of the downsides here - that of endless bureaucracy hampering emergency operations. You see the same thing with ambulances.... slow as molasses driving and the filling out of paperwork before taking the injured to hospital etc.... lives are lost every day because of this sort of ineptitude. If there's a lesson from this disaster to be learned by the authorities, it is to DROP THE PAPERWORK when an emergency situation happens!

3. The media, as always, have blown the nuclear thing WAY out of proportion. I spent days near the Fukushima reactors and there was never any danger THERE, let alone in Tokyo or anywhere further away. I saw first hand the radiation scanners doing their jobs and turning up no dangerous levels of radiation anywhere.

4. The focus for aid and immediate assistance needs to be on getting water, fuel, food and warm clothes/blankets to those in the Fukushima and Miyagi prefectures. The Japanese government has been saying not to take these up there ourselves, but after seeing their lack of action in doing exactly that, I'm going to ignore that and as soon as I'm finished with this TV crew, I'm going to take a load of supplies up there or give it physically to someone I know who is going up there.

5. BEWARE of aid scams etc purporting to help the quake victims. Remember that this is a first world nation. Japan isn't poor. To put it in perspective, the government dumped over 28 trillion yen into the money market just to keep the yen stable. Whilst I'd argue this money could be used to provide real support for the quake/tsunami victims, my point is that Japan as a nation has the money to cope with this disaster. It's a fine ideal to give to the Red Cross Japan, Second Harvest etc.... just make sure you're giving it to the official organisations and not scam artists. And remember, Japanese aid organisations often don't have English language pages or donation options.

6. As was mentioned by Peter Majtan on another thread, one of the best ways to help in the near future will be to come here and shoot your productions etc in this beautiful country. We have so much to offer and the scenery and sights are spectacular. It's also one of the safest countries on earth and a technological paradise akin to Blade Runner if you want that aspect (it's why I'm here!). I know the yen/dollar rate is not favouring the USD right now, but this is a concrete step you can take to help the economy whilst also making your productions that much more unique and authentic if you're looking for Japanese/Asian influences in your work. And it's cherry blossom season soon! One of the most beautiful times of the year to visit!

Anyway, I'll update again soon but for now, thanks to all of you who sent well wishes etc to myself and others here. It's appreciated and good to know that so many people out there care, including but by no means limited to several Red people who emailed me directly last week. What other camera company has such a personal relationship to their customers? Thankyou Red Team!

I'll post a couple of photos I took in the next post.

Cheers from Tokyo,

Paul
 
Last edited:
Some photos:

The night of the quake in Tokyo. With public transportation stopped, Friday evening workers walk home, most walking 10-15km:

IMG_7653as.jpg


Evacuation centre, Iwaki City, Fukushima prefecture:

IMG_7766ss.jpg


Scanning for radiation (all test results were negative):

IMG_7743ss.jpg


IMG_7718ss.jpg


Emergency worker walking past evacuation centre ramen boxes:

IMG_7763ss.jpg


Queuing for water allocation (2L per person per day):

IMG_7801ss.jpg


Cheers,

Paul
 
Incidentally, to understand just how many earthquakes we have had in the last week (and continue to have!), this Google Earth overlay is very useful:

http://www.visceralpsyche.com/misc/USGS_Real-time_Earthquakes.kmz

Head over to Japan and note that we've had over 300 earthquakes in the last seven days alone! It's a fact of life here but that doesn't make the current batch of them any less spectacular. That's a LOT of earthquakes!

Cheers,

Paul
 
Hey Paul. Remember how around a year and a half ago I did all those jobs with our Reds up in Iwate and Miyako?

Can you even believe that half of those towns I shot in have been washed away, and the people ... Don't even want to think about that. I spent the first 2/4 month of my marriage shooting up there against my wife's protests (of course) - it is some of the most beautiful country I have seen in the world and it had a very special place in my heart. It brings a tear to my eye every time I see Pictures of Yamada-machi and Miyako washed to the sea. In Yamada's case the whole town...

I still remember the boat terminal where we departed. The fisherman's house I dined in with the town elders on how we could promote tourism to the region...r

I am glad that the world has come together on this in support. Yes, the Japanese people have been stoic, and more than that. They have shown heart. They have taken cold, the hungry and the homeless victims of this disaster into their homes, and even though I am not japanese by blood, I am proud of the people here.

TEPCO and the govt is another matter altogether.

To all of you out there, Japan will rebuild, Japan will recover, and Japan will keep filming and making movies. Come out here like you always have and keep working with us! Just as much as we need food and shelter, the people need support, and we need to keep our economy strong.

I always told my wife that I wanted to take her to Iwate to show her some of the amazing pristine beauty up there. And now, I am more determined than ever to do so and make this happen.

Cheers, and Peace from Japan.

Ivan
 
Thanks Paul for the informative update.

Graeme
 
6. As was mentioned by Peter Majtan on another thread, one of the best ways to help in the near future will be to come here and shoot your productions etc in this beautiful country.

I'm going to come later this year and seriously shoot volcanoes - and there are few better places to do that! I'd like to make it a lightweight trip so probably will await an EPIC, although that might depend on level of volcanic activity.

Mike
 
Paul,

Welcome back to Tokyo. I was wondering what you were up to. I should have guessed :-)

Sadly, you have confirmed my worst fears concerning the relief effort post-quake/tsunami.

Japan is a wonderful place. That's why we stay. BUT, goddamn it! Did they learn nothing from the Kobe fiasco???!!! Apparently not.

Right after it was humanly possible, they should have gotten government representatives into all the affected areas with Sat. phones if necessary. Japan has NO shortage of government employees/paper pushers. I just saw three cops at an intersection controlling traffic during a blackout when one would have sufficed. I want to pull my hair out.

Those reps. need to be in those locations. Air drop them in if the roads are washed out -- and many were. Then, find out exactly what the people need. From the mouths of the people. Some of the supplies that are making it in aren't what the people need.

Put someone in charge and make it clear to him that he's responsible for the running of the overall operation. Find someone who is a LEADER and knows WTF he's doing.

Then send the supplies requests to a command and control center in Tokyo and get those birds in the air and trucks on the road and get the supplies to these people, the right supplies, and keep them going for as long as it takes. It will be a lot easier for them to recover if the relief effort is handled properly.

I admit, I am emotional about this. Of course something like this isn't easy. But I believe, ONCE AGAIN, the government has fallen down on the job. Why do we keep relying on these incompetents?

What we need is a private Disaster Strike Force with the authority to get things done. The guy in charge gets his ass canned if he's not on top of things in three days. Get someones else in there who can take care of business. Period.

I have this sick feeling that we'll be watching stories of bureaucratic bungling once again in documentaries on this monumental disaster in the future. A fat lot of good that will do for the people who froze to death.
 
Thanks Paul for the update on the situation over there. good luck

it's clear how slow their government seem to react, and it is indeed a matter of fact all media mostly reports about Fukushima and much less about the people.

the only images we mostly see are over and over again abouth the nucleair plant, not about the real situation going on.
 
1. The Japanese are the most calm, orderly and stoic people I have ever had the pleasure to be among. No looting, no riots, no complaining.... just a determination to get on with fixing the devastation and rebuilding their lives. It's an honour to live here and be a part of that.

2. The Japanese government has been ridiculously slow and inefficient at getting mobilised and getting aid to those who need it up north. We were allowed onto the freeway heading south back to Tokyo as we were a media car, and I was angered to see NO TRUCKS or other aid vehicles heading in the opposite direction, FIVE DAYS AFTER the tsunami had hit. The highway was literally empty. Were I in charge, I'd have seconded 30% of all trucks and buses nationwide to immediately ferry supplies up north from Tokyo to Fukushima and Miyagi prefectures. Many locals have complained about the same thing. It's disgusting and unfortunately shows up one of the downsides here - that of endless bureaucracy hampering emergency operations. You see the same thing with ambulances.... slow as molasses driving and the filling out of paperwork before taking the injured to hospital etc.... lives are lost every day because of this sort of ineptitude. If there's a lesson from this disaster to be learned by the authorities, it is to DROP THE PAPERWORK when an emergency situation happens!
Glad you guys in Nippon are safe. Paul, do you think your observation regarding the governments sense of urgency (or lack thereof) might be a consequence of point #1 above?
 
3. The media, as always, have blown the nuclear thing WAY out of proportion. I spent days near the Fukushima reactors and there was never any danger THERE, let alone in Tokyo or anywhere further away. I saw first hand the radiation scanners doing their jobs and turning up no dangerous levels of radiation anywhere.


The top of multiple nuclear reactor containment vessels blew up on camera. There is radioactive steam escaping. There's a Japanese gov't 30km exclusion zone. The U.S. gov't has advised citizens to not go within 100km of the site. There are numerous reports of much higher than normal radiation level readings in the water and the food. Japan has shut down its food exports due to contamination concerns.

The current status of the reactors:
http://www.iaea.org/newscenter/news/tsunamiupdate01.html

Unless your other occupation is as the world's leading expert on simultaneous multiple reactor meltdowns, you should probably refrain from making statements that everything's hunky dory and the hype being the media's fault.

I appreciate your other comments and insights.
 
The top of multiple nuclear reactor containment vessels blew up on camera.

That is not correct. What exploded was the outer shell buildings, which are made of sheet metal on a steel frame... Compared to the containment and pressure vessels, they are very flimsy and are not part of the containment systems.

The thick concrete steel containment vessels in reactors 1, 4, 5 and 6 are all intact. There is some uncertantity as to whether the primary containment in reactors and 2 and 3 have suffered some damage.
 
Glad you guys in Nippon are safe. Paul, do you think your observation regarding the governments sense of urgency (or lack thereof) might be a consequence of point #1 above?
I think it's due to a lack of leadership. This country is very conformist in its thinking, which means that anyone who upsets the 'wa' or social harmony is looked down upon. This includes, in my view, those who try to stand up and lead. So no one is willing to take up the mantle of leader in case they are ostracised. It's a big problem here and not limited to emergency response situations. No one wants to take risks any more. But that "safe decisions are best" mentality is hurting the economy across many industries. The Japanese high tech companies are being overtaken by new rivals (Red being a classic example here) with vision and most importantly, leadership to take calculated risks where the potential rewards are great.

Cheers,

Paul
 
The top of multiple nuclear reactor containment vessels blew up on camera. There is radioactive steam escaping. There's a Japanese gov't 30km exclusion zone. The U.S. gov't has advised citizens to not go within 100km of the site. There are numerous reports of much higher than normal radiation level readings in the water and the food. Japan has shut down its food exports due to contamination concerns.

The current status of the reactors:
http://www.iaea.org/newscenter/news/tsunamiupdate01.html

Unless your other occupation is as the world's leading expert on simultaneous multiple reactor meltdowns, you should probably refrain from making statements that everything's hunky dory and the hype being the media's fault.

I appreciate your other comments and insights.
Hi Anthony,

I am by no means an expert, however I do have training in nuclear defense from my nine years in the military....

NBCD1.jpg


NBCD2.jpg


Having observed the radiation scanners and geiger counters first hand at Iwaki city after the second outer casing blowout (roughly 50km away), and understanding what levels are considered dangerous, I am confident that my assessment remains accurate, especially here in Tokyo which is over 200km away. I'm not saying there is no radiation increase. What I'm saying is that it's not at levels harmful to human health. The media beats up on the 40x or 100x normal background radiation levels and people's automatic reaction is to assume the worst. But without the needed context of what a harmful level is, those multiples are meaningless. Here's a handy chart to put the radiation levels in perspective, courtesy of XKCD:

http://blog.xkcd.com/2011/03/19/radiation-chart/

In short - I've spent years around radar dishes, been a pilot (which means higher received radiation due to the thinner atmosphere at altitude) and used mobile phones next to my head for as long as they've been around. In the greater scheme of things, all these have probably been far more harmful to me than the radiation from Fukushima even when I was close to it last week.

Other than not eating spinach from the affected area (not that I'd normally eat it anyway, I'm not a fan!) I'm happy that I'm perfectly healthy and will continue to be so living here in Tokyo, or even closer to Fukushima if I lived there.

Hope this helps alleviate your worries somewhat.

Cheers from Tokyo,

Paul
 
Well said Paul. I love radiation.

No, seriously. I'm a hazmat tech as well as a fireman, I'm trained in mitigating radiological accidents (in fact my final assessment exercise was a simulated accident in a lab containing radioisotopes) and counter-terrorism (and a terrorist attack utilizing WMDs is just an *intentional* hazmat situation when you think about it).

I'd much prefer to deal with radiation than any of the other potential nasties; it can be easily detected using simple, cheap instruments with 100% reliability and accuracy, and the ways of minimizing exposure are simple enough a child can understand them: time, distance, shielding.

Kudos to the firemen and engineers getting up close and personal with the reactors, however; that's a different kettle of fish and some significant courage is on display there.

Mike
 
Hi Anthony,
What I'm saying is that it's not at levels harmful to human health. The media beats up on the 40x or 100x normal background radiation levels and people's automatic reaction is to assume the worst. But without the needed context of what a harmful level is, those multiples are meaningless.

Other than not eating spinach from the affected area (not that I'd normally eat it anyway, I'm not a fan!) I'm happy that I'm perfectly healthy and will continue to be so living here in Tokyo, or even closer to Fukushima if I lived there.

Hope this helps alleviate your worries somewhat.

Cheers from Tokyo,

Paul

You should probably let the Japanese Self Defense Forces and the Nuclear workers know...they're wasting alot of time and energy worrying in Northern Japan.

It looks like your certificates are for NBC warfare training courses aboard boats is that correct? If so, I'm a little confused as to what your qualifications have to do with landbased nuclear reactor meltdowns.

I've noticed that alot of the press releases read "there is no immediate threat to human health".
Leaks of this type that cause increases in radiation levels may also be a long term threat to human health, not necessarily in the immediate. And media reports do contextualize the relative levels of radiation, at least some of the ones I've read.
Also, 4 of the 6 reactors are now ranked at Level 5, with Chernobyl being a 7. Chernobyl's legacy is the long term damage that resulted from the radiation.

It looks like they had to evacuate the plant yet again this morning due to rising radiation levels.....i dunno Paul, it looks like something more than trivial is happening here. But I'm not trying to argue with you.
I wish you all the best in Japan, and the best for everything on this planet as far as nuclear meltdown is concerned.
 
Well said Paul. I love radiation.

No, seriously. I'm a hazmat tech as well as a fireman, I'm trained in mitigating radiological accidents (in fact my final assessment exercise was a simulated accident in a lab containing radioisotopes) and counter-terrorism (and a terrorist attack utilizing WMDs is just an *intentional* hazmat situation when you think about it).

I'd much prefer to deal with radiation than any of the other potential nasties; it can be easily detected using simple, cheap instruments with 100% reliability and accuracy, and the ways of minimizing exposure are simple enough a child can understand them: time, distance, shielding.

Kudos to the firemen and engineers getting up close and personal with the reactors, however; that's a different kettle of fish and some significant courage is on display there.

Mike

MIke, these statements are confusing. The best way to deal with radiation is with time, distance, and shielding? That sounds like no solution at all.

How can you say "I love radiation" and then say, "the guys up close and personal to it is a different kettle of fish and significant courage on display".
I agree with you that those guys are pulling alot of weight, and have tremendous amounts of courage.

Maybe it's time the obvious was stated. No more nuclear reactors.

How about we invest the tens of billions of dollars they cost into a variety of non-poisonous power generating possibilities instead, and stop wasting the energy we do have.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top