I understand the emotions. It is a matter of pride for any country to have such high tech manufacturing.
However, trying to create the entire supply chain in the country, may not be the most efficient approach. It may have political overtones, however, if one looks at the net total benefit to the economy, then it may not be the best approach.
Apple's iPhone is manufactured by Foxconn in China. If Apple would have tried to set up that manufacturing in US, then one can safely say that iPhone would not have sold such massive numbers. The iPhone is a market leader in many geographies, in its segment. By selling in such volumes, it creates more value for US, than a limited number of completely made in US product.
In a high value, low volume product like the Epics, RED ones etc, one can afford to charge a sufficient "production premium" for being Made in USA. However, just imagine a scenario, where RED is able to source components (or manufacture in India/China) thereby creating low priced and great quality products taking the market away from a certain Japanese giant. Don't you think that will result in more value creation in US?
Sharing a link to a news report which quotes the study by the IT Industry.
http://money.cnn.com/2004/03/30/news...cing/index.htm
which states the benefits of outsourcing.
We are a global economy and all the economies are more interlinked. When you guys sneeze, we catch cold. Today, I read in papers that the unemployment rate in US is some 20%. That is truly shocking. That needs some hard economic decisions by the Govt. One can't just stimulate the economy by increased spending...
In one of your earlier posts you had talked about War (read decimating competition). How on earth are you going to do that, with high cost of manufacturing? I am not challenging the ability of the amazing guys and gals working in RED or their innovativeness or your fantastic leadership skills. Am just concerned that RED could have ensured more value to the American economy by not restricting its manufacturing to CA/USA.
Regards,
Sabyasachi